• A while ago, I came across an Iltalehti story shared on their Facebook page. The headline read: Kouluissa muhii iso kriisi. Nyt puhuvat opettajat: “Tilannehan räjähtää käsiin” [A big crisis is brewing in schools. Now teachers speak out: “The situation is about to explode”].

    There is plenty to say about the language of urgency and securitization that runs through Finnish media coverage of immigrants, not to mention the racism that predictably fills the comments under stories like this. What stood out to me here, though, was the subhead — the first thing Iltalehti’s Facebook followers would’ve seen.

    It read: Opettajat kokevat, että maahanmuuttajataustaiset oppilaat eristäytyvät omiin ryhmiinsä, mikä vaikeuttaa kielen oppimista [Teachers feel that students with immigrant backgrounds are isolating themselves into their own groups, which makes language learning harder].

    This kind of racialized sensationalism is not particularly unusual in Finnish media. News outlets have also learned that social media algorithms reward outrage, so engagement increasingly depends on rage bait gimmicks. And what easier target is there than immigrants, a group with comparatively little power to shape the stories being told about them?

    Once you start paying attention to the visual choices in Finnish media coverage, certain patterns become difficult to ignore. Stories about disturbances on the Helsinki metro are accompanied by photos from stations in Eastern Helsinki, regardless of where the incident actually took place. When someone being arrested or tried is not white, the blurring or pixelation of their face still leaves just enough skin visible for their race to remain legible. Stories about student benefits, meanwhile, seem remarkably fond of photos of BIPOC or international students, as though white Finnish students had somehow never needed financial aid.

    Seeing this particular story on Facebook, though, reminded me of a brilliant book I read last year: Racecraft (2012), by sisters Karen and Barbara Fields.

    The Fields sisters introduce the concept of “racecraft” to describe the social processes that make race seem natural and self-evident. Their argument turns a familiar assumption around. We often think racism exists because society contains different racial groups. The Fields sisters argue that the process also works in the opposite direction: people are repeatedly treated, categorised, separated, and understood through racism, and these practices make racial categories themselves appear “natural”. In other words, racist practices help produce the very idea of race.

    This is where the “craft” in racecraft comes in. The term refers to witchcraft: in older forms of magical thinking, bad fortune might be explained by a curse rather than by the actual chain of events that caused it. Similarly, racecraft gives social inequality a seemingly obvious explanation, race, while hiding the human actions and institutions that produced that inequality in the first place. What was created through laws, discrimination, and unequal treatment starts to look as though it simply follows from the supposed characteristic of the people affected.

    That is the central trick of racecraft: the consequences of racism are made to appear as characteristics of the people subjected to it. The social process disappears, and the target starts to look like the cause.

    The Fields sisters illustrate this with the seemingly neutral statement “Black Southerners were segregated because of their skin color”. At first, it sounds ordinary and harmless enough. But this innocent sentence carries a twisted logic and causality. Here’s how it performs racecraft:

    It says segregation “happened” to Black Southerners.

    It blames “their skin color” as the cause.

    The “segregationists” — the people and institutions who actually enforced segregation laws — are never mentioned.

    The logic has beed reversed: the effect (segregation) is made to seem like it was caused by a trait of the victim (skin color) rather than by the actions of the aggressor (segregationists). In other words, a little grammatical sleight of hand turns racism from “something people do” into “something other people are”. This is how racecraft works.

    The same twisted logic hides inside that headline about Finnish schools. The supposed crisis is brewing because “immigrant background students isolate themselves”. The students are grammatically the ones doing the isolating, and the phrasing does not suggest that this could be shaped by the school environment, peer behavior, institutional neglect, power relations, or Finnish society’s historical hostility toward newcomers with a different skin tone.

    It reads as if those students with immigrant backgrounds lovingly and willingly choose to be excluded, stay lonely, and not be invited to peer gatherings because that’s how they are! And just like that, the focus shifts from the systems that exclude to the supposed habits of the excluded.

    This is racecraft performing its favourite trick, that is, making the target look like the source of the problem while the real problem quietly slips out of view. We need to remind these prophets of national panic that Finland is not “räjähtämässä”. What is cracking is their insistence on pretending that the country should still look the way they fantasise it once did. The real crisis is not immigrant kids, but the panic of those confronted with a Finland they refuse to accept.

    Erfan Fatehi

    How to cite this article (APA style)

    Fatehi, E. (2026, November 5). Racecraft; How Finnish media makes immigrants the problem. Borderlines. Available at: https://borderlinesfi.blog/en/2026/11/05/racecraft-how-finnish-media-makes-immigrants-the-problem/ (Accessed: your date)

    References

    Fields, K. E., & Fields, B. J. (2012). Racecraft: The soul of inequality in American life. Verso.

    Rimppi, S. (2025, May 26). Kouluissa muhii iso kriisi: Nyt puhuvat opettajat: “Tilannehan räjähtää käsiin”. Iltalehti. https://www.iltalehti.fi/kotimaa/a/ac6be84a-6780-44fb-ac6b-a6ed3f416cb2

  • When Keir Starmer ran for the Labour leadership in 2020, he promised to defend freedom of movement and build an immigration system based on compassion and dignity. By January 2021, freedom of movement was scrapped from his programme. By November 2022, Starmer (who in the late 1980s served on the editorial board of Socialist Alternatives, a Trotskyist red and green journal that described itself as “the human face of the hard left”) was telling business leaders that Britain had to end its “immigration dependency” and stop relying on “cheap labour”.

    In the meantime, critics were complaining that Labour was abandoning its legacy and taking on an increasingly right-wing character, so Starmer was only one part of a broader problem. Labour’s 2024 programme placed border security among its first priorities and promised a new Border Security Command. Guardian columnist Aditya Chakrabortty reported that the manifesto mentioned “business” about 60 times, “poverty” only 14 times and “inequality” once. Political scientist Kevin Farnsworth found its language and values closer to Edward Heath’s Conservative platform of 1974 than to almost any earlier Labour manifesto.

    Once in power, the vocabulary hardened further. In May 2025, Starmer reached for the old Brexit slogan “take back control”, described what preceded him as “an experiment in open borders”, and warned that Britain risked becoming an “island of strangers”. His government proposed tougher English requirements and a standard route to permanent settlement twice as long as before, increasing the usual period from five years to ten. Starmer later regretted the phrasing, but not the policy direction, as his government proceeded with tougher immigration measures.

    As expected, after all that pandering for a stray extremist vote or two, the ballot box remained stubbornly unimpressed for Labour. Immediately after Labour’s 2025 immigration White Paper, Ipsos found Reform UK trusted on immigration by 37 percent of the public, while only about a quarter trusted Labour. Nigel Farage personally led Starmer by 28 percent to 15 percent. By January 2026, Reform led Labour by 44 percent to 23 percent on managing immigration and asylum. Then, Reform UK achieved historic victories over Labour in the May 2026 UK local elections.

    This is one of the left’s oldest traps, and somehow still one of its favourite ones to walk into. If a centre left party accepts the right’s account of what is wrong, it also lends credibility to the people who wrote that account in the first place. Also, the parties that built their politics around that claim no longer look extreme, but simply ahead of the curve. If you present immigration as THE crisis, voters are naturally drawn toward those who have spent years insisting exactly that (copies rarely outsell originals!). This is precisely why Finland should pay attention.

    Chasing the Finns Party onto its own turf

    SDP is now putting tougher integration language much closer to the centre of its politics. Its 2026 political programme says access to social benefits can be linked to studying Finnish or Swedish and to efforts to integrate and find work. In August this year, the party went further, proposing that social security could be tied to language study and that free interpreting might be limited after a certain period in Finland.

    Of course none of this is entirely new, and the argument cannot be that Lindtman’s leadership has imported something utterly foreign into SDP. In 2010, SDP leader Jutta Urpilainen addressed the immigrants with the phrase “Maassa maan tavalla” and stressed language, work and respect for Finnish rules while mourning what she called the failure of the Finnish immigration system. Yle, back then, reported that immigration policy across Finnish politics was hardening as parties worried about the rising True Finns, while The True Finns happily accused their competitors of copying them for votes.

    So there is a simple question worth asking. Did trying to compete on this terrain contain the Finns Party? The very next parliamentary election produced the famous 2011 surge. The Finns Party jumped to 19.1 percent and 39 seats, gaining 34 seats in a historic victory. In 2023 it went further, winning 20.1 percent, becoming Finland’s second largest party and entering government. And the party is rising again. Yle’s September 2026 poll puts it at 16.3 percent after another increase, with its support among working class voters now roughly level with SDP’s.

    That history makes the present strategy look painfully familiar rather than particularly clever. Although SDP’s parliamentary group leader denies that the party is courting Finns Party voters, whatever label is attached to the strategy, the political direction is clear enough. Finnish and Swedish Social Democrats have coordinated election themes for over a year, with crime and immigration central to a so-called effort to win back voters from the populist right, drawing partly on the more extreme Danish model.

    That said, this is not the only problem with SDP falling into an old trap or borrowing the language of racist parties. There are serious flaws in the policy itself, and in the fantasy that playing around language and integration will somehow cure SDP’s troubles at the ballot box.

    First, immigrants receiving unemployment support already face integration obligations. Eligibility for unemployment security requires participation in the initial assessment and services agreed in an integration plan, including integration training. Refusing or abandoning required services can lead to a waiting period or loss of entitlement to unemployment security. The idea that the present system contains no duties is therefore simply false.

    Second, SDP’s supposedly clever fix rests on a familiar right-wing populist fiction that there is nothing wrong with the perfect system, and the real problem is “lazy immigrants” refusing to do their part. Punishment is a strange response when access to adequate language education or integration training is itself part of the problem. For example, a Ministry of Economic Affairs and Employment report states that, on 30 April 2024, about 4,700 immigrant job seekers were waiting for either an initial assessment or integration related training. After the initial assessment, the average wait for integration training was about 2.8 months. On top of that, language courses are not equally accessible to everyone because of both legislation and practical opportunities to participate. There is also particular difficulty for people already working, studying, or living outside the principal integration system. The question, then, is how this already malfunctioning system is supposed to improve while the government plans to strip another €47 million from integration services?

    Third, SDP is hardly inventing anything new here. Finland’s current governing coalition, which includes the Finns Party, is already pushing a similar logic through a lower integration benefit for some recent immigrants, with roughly €80 to €100 more per month available after reaching a sufficient level of Finnish or Swedish. The SDP proposal is not identical. But perhaps SDP officials must be asked how comfortable they are speaking the same dehumanising political language?

    Fourth, SDP seems oddly selective about which barriers to integration deserve political urgency. Weak Finnish language skills are widely recognised as a barrier to employment, even for qualified applicants, so many job seekers already have every practical reason to learn Finnish. But why is SDP so eager to discipline immigrants over language while showing far less urgency about one of the Finnish labour market’s most persistent failures? Where is the comparable push to tackle discrimination in hiring, for example through stronger anti-discrimination employment law in their 2026 program? In sociologist Akhlaq Ahmad’s updated 2024 hiring experiment, researchers sent 10000 fictitious job applications from applicants who were essentially equally qualified. They had Finnish schooling and excellent Finnish. Applicants with standard Finnish names were still more than twice as likely to receive interview calls as applicants with Somali or Iraqi names. The older experiment had already produced a stark result. Applicants with Finnish names received 390 interview invitations per thousand applications, compared with 134 for Iraqi names and 99 for Somali names, despite equal qualifications and excellent Finnish.

    Walking away is not a strategy

    Before accepting another round of political alarm about immigration, it is always worth checking whether the emergency exists in the form being advertised. A 2025 study by Diak, based on Statistics Finland and Kela data, found that foreign language speakers made a net positive contribution to Finland’s public finances. In 2023 they paid roughly 2.7 billion euros in taxes while receiving 2.4 billion euros in income transfers, leaving a positive balance of about 225 million euros. Imaginary claims of mounting welfare dependency fare no better.

    Although there are some fair caveats and questions around the Diak study and how broadly its results can be interpreted, its finding on taxes and transfers still stands. That finding, of course, should not be taken to mean that immigration as a whole necessarily pays for itself or has a necessarily positive fiscal effect, since the wider fiscal effect depends on factors such as employment, age structure, migration type, and use of public services.

    Meanwhile, Kela figures reported in September 2026 found that while Finland’s foreign language population had grown considerably, the proportion of foreign language adults receiving basic social assistance fell from 23 percent in 2017 to 18 percent in 2025. The share receiving labour market subsidy fell from 24 percent to 16 percent.

    None of this means, of course, immigrants face no serious barriers in Finland, or that integration is free of problems. But the figures matter politically because SDP is not making these choices in an evidence-free vacuum. SDP is clearly worried about working class voters moving to the Finns Party, and that concern is not fictional. However, SDP’s political struggle has another flank: The Left Alliance.

    The same poll that puts SDP at 22.6 percent has the Left Alliance at 11.7 percent, its strongest result in Yle’s polling series since records began in 1994. The report has two rather inconvenient facts for SDP, that is, the Finns Party is nearly level with it among working class voters, while its clearest voter losses are going to the Left Alliance. This is precisely where political possibility opens for the left through activism and resistance.

    This is a reminder for anyone invested in the future of Finland’s left. SDP may be looking anxiously to its right, but it also knows that movement in that direction can cost support on its left. That gives trade unionists, party members, youth organisations, migrant organisations and the wider left a source of real political pressure. A centre left party that fears losing voters in both directions can still be pulled back.

    But writing SDP off entirely by those on the left would surrender that pressure, and result in disaster in the long term. The temptation to say “enough is enough, let SDP rot!” and switching allegiance to the Left Alliance or Greens may be understandable but treating SDP as no longer worth fighting over is another politically dangerous matter, leaving the country’s most powerful centre left institution to those perfectly happy to push it further right.

    The unpleasant truth is that mainstream parties matter disproportionately. The support for the Left Alliance and Greens can therefore act as pressure on SDP rather than a reason to declare SDP politically irrelevant. The fate of a mainstream centre left party matters far beyond the people who vote for it. Such a party can lead governments, fill ministries, write coalition programmes and set the boundaries of what becomes ordinary centre left policy.

    Britain offers the warning. Labour kept borrowing the right’s vocabulary, yet Reform remained far more trusted on immigration and hardened its grip on power. Finland does not need to repeat the experiment. The urgent response is pressure before the drift hardens into identity, that is, pressure from party members, unions, youth organisations, local branches, researchers, migrant organisations, journalists and the wider left. The right already has parties willing to speak its language. Finland does not need its largest left party competing for the microphone.

    Erfan Fatehi

    How to cite this article (APA style)

    Fatehi, E. (2026, October 16). The right does not need a better megaphone on immigration: Britain’s warning for Finland’s SDP. Borderlines. https://borderlinesfi.blog/en/2026/10/16/the-right-does-not-need-a-better-megaphone-on-immigration-britains-warning-for-finlands-sdp/ (Accessed: your date)

  • Bypassing paper fences

    In Finland, ignoring a person who is in danger may constitute a crime. If someone knows that another person is in danger — for example, in the case of a workplace accident, abuse, or a threat of an injury or death — but fails to help them (providing that helping would not pose a significant threat to themselves), Chapter 21 of the Criminal Law defines such behavior as either “abandonment” (Section 14) or “neglect of rescue” (Section 15). Committing such crimes can lead to a serious punishment, ranging from a fine to up to two years in prison. What’s important, the law establishes that the negligent person may also be held responsible for the harm caused by failing to provide help.

    States, too, can abandon people in danger or neglect rescue — often intentionally. This is particularly evident when it comes to helping migrants who flee from dangerous situations in the country of citizenship in the hope of finding safety (Motte, 2024; CIDOB, n.d.; ECRE, 2024; Merikoski et al., 2024).

    There are regulated legal mechanisms for states to help migrants at risk. The Refugee Convention of 1951 obliges a state that has signed it to protect people fleeing from persecution. According to the United Nations, Finland signed the Convention on October 10, 1968.

    Article 1A of the Convention defines a refugee as is a person in need of international protection. In other words, this is:

    “any person who <…> owing to well-founded fear of being persecuted for reasons of race, religion, nationality, membership of a particular social group or political opinion, is outside the country of his nationality and is unable or, owing to such fear, is unwilling to avail himself of the protection of that country; or who, not having a nationality and being outside the country of his former habitual residence as a result of such events, is unable or, owing to such fear, is unwilling to return to it <…>”

    In Articles 31.1 and 32.1, states collectively decided that a country (that includes Finland):

    “shall not impose penalties, on account of their illegal entry or presence, on refugees who, coming directly from a territory where their life or freedom was threatened in the sense of article 1, enter or are present in their territory without authorization, provided they present themselves without delay to the authorities and show good cause for their illegal entry or presence” — Article 31.1.

    “The Contracting States shall not expel a refugee lawfully in their territory save on grounds of national security or public order.” — Article 32.1.

    Borderlines interviewed two people who could apply for asylum in Finland on these grounds.

    Anatoly (personal details changed) is a trans man from Eastern Europe. There, he actively participated in queer activism. As a result, in 2018, he received death threats and was beaten so heavily that he still has to deal with the consequences of those injuries. “Bruises and scrapes, whatever, but I ended up with some pretty bad contusions and a concussion that’s still giving me neurological crap seven years later.”

    Since Finland has signed the Refugee Convention, people such as Anatoly and Ruslan could hope to apply for asylum and expect a positive decision after Migri assessed their situations.

    However, when powerful politicians and parties believe that such people are not worthy of living in Finland, they may seek ways to stay negligent – either by adopting new laws or by violating existing ones (Motte, 2024; CIDOB, n.d., ECRE, 2024; Merikoski et al., 2024).

    As sociologist Erna Bodström explains in her book Refugee Crisis: My Journey to the Europe’s External Borders (2023), recent decades in Europe have brought tighter external borders even as internal borders are becoming more open. This trend is often called Fortress Europe. It is built to “protect” Europe from forced migration. As a result, reaching safety in Europe in order to apply for asylum has become extremely difficult: it requires first entering a country – usually, with a visa, a residence permit, or by crossing the border.

    Unsplash/Daniel Bernard

    After 2015, many states at Europe’s external borders built fences — particularly in the Balkans — to stop people on the move. These barriers did little to prevent crossings; instead, people fleeing from danger simply started trying to pass “under, over, or around fences“. In Greece, and later on the Polish-Belarusian border, fences became associated with violent border-guard practices in which people who had already crossed the border were forced back. These practices are known as pushbacks. Human rights organisations have documented pushbacks and the associated violence, humiliation, and abuse. Such actions clearly violate the Refugee Convention, which guarantees the right to seek asylum once a border is crossed, and a fence built cannot remove that right either.

    Borders, however, are not only made of metal and concrete. Bodström recalls historian David S. Wyman’s (1968) arguement that borders can also be “paper fences” – bureaucratic and legal barriers designed to obstruct access to protection. These include visa rules that make entry challenging and very expensive as well as bureaucratic criteria and procedures for asylum that make obtaing it nearly impossible.

    Unsplash/Alexander Grey

    Finland is no exception. Finland has been continuously withdrawing from providing protection over the course of the 21st century. Here, we focus on one key aspect of the Aliens Act.

    In practice, it means that even though the Refugee Convention allows a fleeing person to receive protection in another country, Finland can still deny safety if a person has not experienced direct persecution, or if Migri officials do not believe they did (Bodström, 2023). Denied asylum doesn’t mean that the applicant would have a safe life in their country of origin, would stop facing persecution, or that return would be possible at all. The danger remains.

    Whether physical or bureaucratic, both forms of fencing are meant to exclude certain people from their basic rights granted by the Refugee Convention.

    People who flee from danger are often aware of this even before arriving in Finland.

    Ruslan: – I was in a queer NGO “Raduga” in Kremnegrad (details changed) while finishing my studies, and people there told that it’s really hard to get asylum in the West. You need a case of violence, otherwise they won’t give it to you. They told that some deliberately go on the streets with a rainbow flag or something for queer rights – they know they’ll be beaten or arrested for “homo propaganda” – and they never know how this will end. But they need to “make a case”. And even one incident isn’t enough, so people go out many times and just hope they won‘t end up in hospital with a head injury – due to violence from strangers, police, or both.

    Borderlines interviewer: – When you came to Finland, did you ever think about applying for asylum?

    – Yes, but I feel hopeless about this. I never experienced any violence, I always tried to be cautious and closeted. <Migri officials> need evidence of violence in order to give you asylum, otherwise they just say that you don’t deserve it.

    – Did you think you had a chance to get asylum, or did you feel they would refuse you anyway?

    – I don’t think I’d get anything. Now I already know that even people who faced threats or violence haven’t got anything.

    People can also realise that Finnish bureaucracy evades providing protection:

    “After hearing many stories about what happened to other LGBT+ asylum seekers, I lost hope of having a real chance to get asylum. It feels as if someone would have to almost kill me to be considered eligible. Structural, governmental, or social harm is not seen as sufficient grounds.” – Huseyin

    Over time, people may start believing in the “standards” the Finnish laws claim, downplaying their own experiences:

    “things were unpleasant and somewhat unsafe, but not catastrophic, not full-on “horror-horror.” – Anatoly wrote about the threats and attacks he experienced.

    Tightening access to asylum doesn’t reduce people’s need for safety. People continue to flee danger, avoiding applying for asylum if possible. This way, the state “outsources” its responsibility to provide safety to others who have no legal obligation to provide it – only moral principles.

    As Bodström mentions, this means that when asylum is nearly unobtainable, some people fleeing danger would try to escape “under, over, or around” physical fences. Here we highlight that this is also true for paper fences, as Anatoly and Ruslan’s stories show us. They do so by applying for work-, study-, and family-based residence permits (IOM, 2018; OECD, 2016; Refugee Council of Australia, 2019). Migrants with such permits are still forced migrants: they cannot go back to their country of origin without risking their lives. Yet their protection is “delegated” to their employers, universities, and spouses.

    Unsplash/Etienne Gicardet

    Studies, work and family may seem as safe and stable ways of migration while asylum is seen as dangerous and unreliable. However, this assumption is false.

    A forced migrant’s safety becomes dependent on the goodwill of others and on bureaucracy that has not been designed to protect people from danger. We follow how Anatoly and Ruslan’s stories unfold.

    Coming to Finland is very difficult — a reality faced by many migrants, regardless of whether they apply for asylum or not. Even so, many believe that alternatives to asylum might be an easier and more secure path to safety. Anatoly, for example, first moved to another EU country for studies. However, his funds ran out and his health deteriorated. Anatoly wasn’t able to continue his studies and had to come back to Eastern Europe. Many of Anatoly’s friends had already left Eastern Europe and applied for asylum elsewhere. Anatoly also considered applying for asylum but the prospect of living in a “refugee camp” in long-term uncertainty repelled him.

    “The prospect of living in a camp — where things are often, honestly, really horrible, and there’s not much you can do about it. Not just bad living conditions, but also unsafe and psychologically rough. Plus, the process is totally unpredictable — sometimes it drags on for years”

    Instead, Anatoly decided to apply for a family-based residence permit – an opportunity that appeared from his new relationship with a person living in Finland. Anatoly came to Finland but his first residence permit application was rejected as well as his appeals to the Administrative and the Supreme Courts. After about three years in Finland, Anatoly was forced to return to Eastern Europe where he had to stay in his apartment out of fear of potential danger. After submitting a new application on the same grounds, Anatoly and his spouse were finally reunited.

    “My very patient spouse, who kindly agreed to stay married until I get permanent residency. If it weren’t for that, I’d probably have to reapply through asylum — though at this point, after all these years, that case would be kinda shaky. I’ve got no other grounds coming up“

    Ruslan moved to Finland on the grounds of work, a route recommended within the Russian queer community as a safer way to escape Russia. Ruslan decided that he would move to Finland immediately after graduating from his medical university.

    “Hearing all of this <about asylum procedures> was scary, and I decided to try to avoid facing all of this. <…> At the queer community, people advised me to go with work. And there were several people who were dreaming about going to Europe through work or school in the future too.”

    Ruslan went through all bureaucracy, found employment in Finland, and applied for a work-based residence permit in 2021. In 2022, he moved to Finland.

    As Anatoly and Ruslan’s stories develop, it becomes clear that the idea of an “easy” migration route is a myth. Instead of the state, protection from danger is informally “delegated” to other actors leaving Anatoly and Ruslan dependent on others, and later even trapped in situations they could not escape – which significantly affected their wellbeing.

    Shortly after family reunification Anatoly’s relationship with his spouse began to change. His spouse didn’t accept his queerness and began to manipulate him. He forced him to dress in female ways, controlled his day schedule – all under the threat that he would divorce Anatoly which would have resulted in Anatoly’s deportation. Anatoly is still living with his spouse and dealing with mental health challenges as well as difficulties accessing trans healthcare in Finland. He has also applied for a permanent residence permit which could grant him independence from his spouse.

    After facing difficulties related to same-sex marriage in Finland and family reunification, Ruslan was forced to change jobs in order to earn a higher income. At the time, he was already under significant stress due to unexpected bureaucratic obstacles. In one of his workplaces, Ruslan openly spoke about his and Huseyin’s story and criticised Finnish politics. Instead of understanding or support, he faced mobbing. Changing jobs again was risky, as unemployment could jeopardise family reunification and lead to his deportation. Ruslan forced himself to continue and endure mobbing, which led to burnout. Even so, he still continued working – first in this workplace, and later in another. Eventually, his contract ended and he left his job. He tried to change professions through vocational education and apprenticeship, but his new employer withdrew support shortly after the college accepted him as a student. Ruslan is currently unemployed. Without a new basis for residency in Finland, both Ruslan and his spouse risk becoming undocumented, deported, separated, and exposed to danger in their countries of citizenship.

    Study-, work-, and family-based residence permits are conditional on income. According to Migri, applicants must meet certain income or savings requirements both to receive and to maintain a residence permit. Because of this, the safety of a forced migrant becomes conditional on the economic factor as well. A person in need of protection will lose it if their work contract ends, studies stop, a relationship breaks down or they are unable to meet the income criteria – in other words, if they can no longer pay the “price” for security. This places a forced migrant at the mercy of their spouse, employer, or university. This situation can last for years – until a permanent permit or citizenship is granted. Recent policy changes under Orpo’s government have raised the income requirements and added new conditions, which likely prolong this period of “stuckness” and uncertainty, further exhausting affected people.

    Forced migrants who avoid applying for asylum also try to conceal the fact that they are forced migrants or “refugees” in order to avoid additional scrutiny from the state.

    “When we were applying for my husband’s family reunification, we initially felt that we shouldn’t write in the form that we can’t go back. We thought, they wouldd decide we were at risk of staying here undocumented and wouldn’t allow us to live in Finland. Only when we contacted a specialist, we became braver. But I remember that even when we were talking to that specialist, we tried to somehow minimise that fact. We felt that just mentioning it would make things worse.” – Ruslan

    “On paper, it looks like my husband is here for work and I’m here just to accompany him, but in reality, he chose Finland because it’s the only place where he can feel safe being himself, something he could never have in his home country.” – Huseyin

    Unsplash/Kelli McClintock

    The state can push others even deeper into hiding one’s true reasons for immigration—to the point where they adopt the state perspective to themselves (Güdük & Desmet, 2022), blame themselves, minimise their own experiences, or even dissociate from them (Shaw & Verghese, 2022).

    Anatoly told us he has been diagnosed with dissociation, and this helps explain why his descriptions of danger and harm appear fragmented and contradictory. For instance, he wrote:

    “I left Eastern Europe in 2018 with a solid political case — like, textbook strong, colourful even. They handled the arrest rough”

    — only to add later that:

    “The awkward thing is, from my point of view, it wasn’t even intentional — just a bit of rough handling, nobody went out of their way to be cruel. It’s just the routine way they treat you — like meat. <…> But there’s an important note here about activism: I chose those risks myself — they’re a direct consequence of my public activity. I’m my own worst enemy :)”

    Similar to a person who abandons or neglects another in danger, Finland does the same towards people fleeing from danger. Through its policies, the government creates conditions that allow Finland to stay away from its duty to protect those in need – in contradiction to the commitments it made under the Refugee Convention. As a result, protection is delegated to others who never consented to this role and may not be even aware of it. While these people keep forced migrants from immeadiate harm , they can also control and exhaust them more. At the same time, forced migrants living under such situations remain hidden from the state.

    “I often feel that <…>, having a residence permit is like wearing a mask. Beneath that mask is someone who truly needs protection. Current immigration policies don’t offer that protection.” – Huseyin

    Unsplash/Teslariu Mihai

    Finland in Fortress Europe

    Borderlines has already covered the story of Huseyin and Ruslan in our posts about homonationalism in the Finnish Marriage Act. Now, however, we focus on the fact that Huseyin’s move to Finland was also an attempt to escape potential threats in Turkey, his country of origin.

    Huseyin moved to Finland on a family-based residence permit as Ruslan’s husband. However, after Ruslan lost the grounds for his own residence permit, the couple now faces the risk of deportation or falling into undocumented status if they fail to find a new legal basis to remain in Finland:

    “I definitely didn’t feel safe being open about it [being queer]. My relatives are very conservative, and they only found out about my situation [same-sex marriage] after I moved to Finland. If I had still been in my home country, <…> they would have tried to force me to marry a woman because, in their eyes, my relationship would bring them ‘shame’ if others found out.”

    In recent years, LGBTQ+ people in Turkey have faced increasing levels of hate crimes—many of which take the form of lynchings that can occur anywhere and at any time (Köylü, 2021; ILGA Europe, 2023). Violence, torture, and ill-treatment of LGBTQ+ activists are also commonly perpetrated by the police (ILGA Europe, 2023).

    In October 2025, a draft law considered by Erdoğan’s government leaked on social media. According to the draft, the proposed 11th Judicial Package would introduce amendments to the penal and civil codes that would severely restrict LGBTQ+ rights. Using vague language referring to “biological sex” and “general morality,” the reforms would criminalize LGBTQ+ expression and its “promotion,” with penalties of up to three years in prison, and up to four years for same-sex couples holding symbolic engagement or wedding ceremonies (Amnesty International, 2025; ECPR – The Loop, n.d.; Human Rights Watch, 2025).

    Political and social conditions do not always change abruptly. Oppression, persecution, and discrimination often develop gradually, and the situation in Turkey illustrates this process clearly. Following the leak, public protests erupted across Turkey, and the draft law was ultimately withdrawn. However, sociologist and organizer with Istanbul Pride and Trans Pride, Jiyan Andiç, noted that “even without this law, it is a dangerous period in which LGBTQ+ people are portrayed as enemies and constructed as an illegal group,” adding that the threat to LGBTQ+ people continues to intensify (Yackley, 2025).

    The categories of “safety” and “danger” are not clear-cut; rather, they exist on a spectrum. At what point should a person fleeing increasingly threatening conditions be considered in need of protection?

    Unsplash/Benjamin Salvatore

    Migration-related situations are also deeply complex. For instance, even if Huseyin were to return to Turkey, Ruslan’s relocation there would be highly problematic: the Turkish state does not recognize same-sex marriage, and asylum is granted under extremely restrictive conditions (UNHCR, n.d.; Asylum Information Database, n.d.).

    Moreover, the European understanding of protection needs, as defined by the UN framework, is itself narrow. In her book Refugee Crisis: My Journey to Europe’s External Borders (2023), sociologist Erna Bodström points out that alternative, broader definitions of refugeehood do exist.

    In 1969, the Organisation of African Unity (OAU) drafted a convention that was later ratified by many African states. This convention not only incorporates the UN Refugee Convention’s definition of a refugee but also extends protection to those forced to flee their homes due to, for example, war, occupation, or serious disturbances of public order.

    “Article 1 Definition of the term “Refugee”. 2.

    “The term “refugee” shall also apply to every person who, owing to external aggression, occupation, foreign domination or events seriously disturbing public order in either part or the whole of his country of origin or nationality, is compelled to leave his place of habitual residence in order to seek refuge in another place outside his country of origin or nationality”

    In 1984, Latin American states adopted the Cartagena Declaration on Refugees. In addition to the UN definition, it includes people compelled to flee due to generalized violence, foreign aggression, internal conflict, or massive violations of human rights.

    Huseyin’s situation could fall within this broader understanding of refugeehood.

    “III. 3.

    <…> in view of the experience gained from the massive flows of refugees in the Central American area, it is necessary to consider enlarging the concept of a refugee, bearing in mind, as far as appropriate and in the light of the situation prevailing in the region, the precedent of the OAU Convention (article 1, paragraph 2) and the doctrine employed in the reports of the Inter-American Commission on Human Rights. Hence the definition or concept of a refugee to be recommended for use in the region is one which, in addition to containing the elements of the 1951 Convention and the 1967 Protocol, includes among refugees persons who have fled their country because their lives, safety or freedom have been threatened by generalized violence, foreign aggression, internal conflicts, massive violation of human rights or other circumstances which have seriously disturbed public order.”

    Still, back in Europe, states are actively trying to restrict who counts as a refugee even under the UN convention.

    In the first post we mentioned that Finnish authorities deliberately build paper and physical fences to stop forced migration, or the moving of people from danger to safety. In her book Refugee Crisis: My Journey to the Europe’s External Borders (2023), sociologist Erna Bodström sums up how the legal system in Finland treats forced migrants and how that changed over the recent decades.

    Sipilä’s government program (2015, cited in Bodström, 2023) required Finland to review its asylum practices and make them similar especially to Sweden. This included wider use of the internal flight alternative, which means denying international protection and requiring an applicant to relocate within their country of origin rather than receive asylum in Finland. In practice, the person is returned and advised to settle outside their “home” region. This was proposed despite the fact that the internal displacement was already common.

    The right to asylum is grounded in international treaties and Finnish law, but the internal flight alternative is not.

    Legal scholar Jessica Schultz noted that this logic started to be applied more widely after the Cold War. The numbers of asylum seekers were rising, and the governments tried to grant asylum to fewer people (Schultz, 2019, cited in Bodström, 2023). A provision on internal flight was added to Finnish law in 2009 in line with an EU directive.

    Asylum decisions are generally confidential, but a man from Mosul, Iraq, allowed his decision to be published. According to it, he reported being previously detained and tortured by the Iraqi army, later threatened with death by ISIS, and having his home blown up. The Finnish Immigration Service concluded these harms were not personal and denied him asylum (Pekkonen, 2016, cited in Bodström, 2023).

    The concept of internal flight was obviously applied to this case. Migri argued that although the man could not return to Mosul due to ISIS, he could safely relocate to Baghdad.

    In addition, under Sipilä’s government, Migri tightened its own asylum evaluation mechanisms.

    In September 2016, Manner & Teittinen (cited in Bodström, 2023), Helsingin Sanomat journalists, interviewed officials from Migri. According to their article, many interviewed officials told that they felt pressured to issue more negative decisions—that is, to deny asylum in practice. Two Migri workers even concealed they had been forced to reject asylum in cases where, in their view, asylum should have been granted.

    The team of researchers Saarikkomäki and others (2018, cited in Bodström, 2023) show that the sharp drop in asylum approvals between 2015 and 2017 cannot be explained only by changes in the law. It was also stricter credibility assessments that contrubuted to harm. The Finnish Immigration Service replied to this that applicants were simply not telling the truth. However, this is not always accurate. Erna Bodström found in her study (2022b, cited in Bodström, 2023) that similar stories may be accepted as sufficiently detailed in one part of a decision but rejected as too vague in another.

    In May 2016, the Finnish Immigration Service published a statement, according to which “one can currently return to all areas of Afghanistan, Iraq, and Somalia without the armed conflicts occurring there in themselves posing a danger to a person due to their mere presence.”

    At the time, ISIS still controlled parts of Iraq, including the city of Mosul with about one million residents. In practice, the statement implied that returns were possible even to areas under ISIS control. Helsingin Sanomat (Manner & Teittinen, 2016, cited in Bodström, 2023) commented that the statement was less about actual conditions in countries like Iraq, Afghanistan, or Somalia, and more about Finland tightening its policy to avoid appearing more welcoming than other European states.

    In reality, Migri’s claim of improved security in Iraq was not based on objective country conditions, but on selective use of information in its report (Bodström, 2022a, cited in Bodström, 2023). Migri manipulated the country information to make a picture of an unwelcoming country for potential asylum seekers and to limit residence permits for people already in Finland.

    Building on the changes adopted back in 2015, Orpo’s coalition came to power in June 2023. Alongside the anti-immigrant Finns Party, the cabinet introduced roughly ten new legislative changes. In 2024, sociologists Erna Bodström and Eveliina Lyyttinen analyzed the reforms implemented by yet another anti-immigrant Finnish government. They noted that the entire policy approach had shifted, coining the term the “uncertainty paradigm.” This refers to how the new measures affect all migrants by increasing uncertainty and insecurity. While each change might seem minor on its own, collectively, they have a significant impact on the lives of migrants.

    Some of these changes are briefly outlined in the next section:

    • The so-called pushback law allows Finnish border guards to carry out pushbacks, forcing people back into uncertain and dangerous situations (Brunnersum, 2025).
    • The processing of asylum claims has been made faster and more superficial, which reduces accuracy, increases stress, and limits the time asylum seekers have to prepare for interviews or access necessary support.
    • The so-called “pathway change” preventing law denies asylum seekers the right to apply for work-, study-, or family-based residence permits, effectively pushing them into undocumented status. In this way, the government “punishes” people for applying for asylum.
    • The duration of residence permits for asylum seekers has been shortened to 1–3 years, with the need for protection reassessed every time a person applies for a renewal.
    • The waiting time for permanent residence has been extended from four to six years.
    • New requirements for permanent residence and citizenship have been introduced: a maximum of three months on unemployment benefits within the last two years, a B1 level of Finnish or Swedish language proficiency, and a citizenship exam (Migri, 2025a, b, c).
    • The residence period required for citizenship for refugees now starts from the date the residence permit is granted, rather than the date asylum was applied for—a difference that can amount to several years.
    • The so-called 3/6 month rule (Brunnersum, 2025) allows Migri to revoke a residence permit after three or six months of unemployment, depending on the type of employment and duration of residence—a condition that is extremely difficult for migrants to meet (Helsinki-Left & TRUST-M, 2024; Bathke, 2024).

    InfoMigrants (Bethke, 2025) examined another law change affecting migrants: government cuts to NGO funding (Ulko- ja turvallisuusministeriö, 2025). As a result, many organizations that provide legal aid and assistance with employment—services crucial for preventing undocumented status and deportation—are facing greater challenges in maintaining staff and programs. This limits the help available to vulnerable people. Consequently, refugees and asylum seekers have fewer avenues for essential support to navigate difficult and dangerous situations.

    Borderlines has named what can potentially come the bureaucratic violence funnel.

    Orpo’s anti-immigration government pushes forced migrants who are now living in Finland toward death, violence, and suffering.

    Harms

    States across the globe persecute and deliberately deny protecting people like Anatoly, Ruslan, and Huseyin who could challenge the state legitimacy in order to keep their own power. Threats and insecurity obviously make people feel scared for their life. This is what social scientists call “emotional regime” (Redy, 2001) or “emotional governance” (Vammen & Kohl, 2023). The government sends a message to certain people who could challenge its legitimacy: “be afraid of us, be scared of fighting against us or changing society”. Anatoly expressed what it means in one sentence: “I just needed to get out”.

    “Life in Russia was scary, and that’s why I was almost always hiding. I had constant anxiety and shame with people <…> I started to dig into polls, articles, discrimination reports, talked to others from the queer community – everything I could find. The more I found the more scared I became. It became clear that people were getting more and more violent, hated more, were afraid of people like me more…” – Ruslan

    “Any somewhat open LGBTQ person will always have something that can be used against them, and for trans people it’s obviously much heavier.” – Anatoly

    Scared and concerned, people flee to other states in hope to find security and dignity there but

    “then came more and more problems, uncertainty, insecurity – and now I don’t even know if I’ll stay here. I don’t feel safe.” – Ruslan

    Ironically, fleeing from the threat of prosecution, unsafety, and fear created by their countries of citizenship, forced migrants find themselves being under similar influence made by other states. As ethnographer Ida Vammen and sociologist Katrine Kohl (2023) mention, these other states also deliberately keep forced migrants frightened and send a message “Do not come here, do not stay here, you will suffer here because we won’t let you live with dignity. We will send you back to death and misery anyway“:

    “But I’m literally under the threat of losing my residence now – and what should I do then? I can’t just decide “oh okay I’ll go home then”. I have no home. Will I be undocumented? Will I be deported? Where will I even be, if I stay alive at all?“ – Ruslan

    “[Family reunification] doesn’t make me feel relieved. <…> Especially nowadays., <…> we live with the constant fear of losing our family life and our sense of safety.” – Huseyin

    “What keeps me calm is knowing there’s not much time left — my permanent residency is under review. I just need to hold out a bit longer. Still, the thought that they might reject it… it terrifies me on some almost superstitious level. I can’t even think about reapplying again. <…> that really wrecked my mental health.“ – Anatoly

    This “superstitious terror“ of the Finnish state, as Anatoly put it, is what Ruslan feels too. Ruslan made it clear that it is not a fear of something abstract, “up there”, but of specific people who create and maintain the system that forces him feel this way:

    “I’m always afraid of authorities. Once as an activist I went to a discussion organised by Sateenkaari (details changed) about LGBTQ asylum seekers. I sat down behind several women. One of them turned to me and asked about who I am. I told I’m an activist from “Turvapaikkahakijoiden oikeuksien polesta”. She somehow sarcastically or condescendingly said, “well that sounds “safe”. And I’m an asylum application specialist from Migri”. That pinned me down speechless. I wanted to talk on that event but I couldn’t. There were several Migri workers there. I was scared to be in the same room with them – especially when my own family reunification was uncertain back then and I was completely alone in Finland.“

    This terror is also found in the pictures that the people who we chatted with made and enhanced with AI. The figures you will see next can be thought as symbols of public officials – Migri workers, police officers, court judges. All of them are painted as scary creatures that are violent through bureaucracy – a judge’s gavel, a projector. One of Huseyin’s creatures also depict surveillance for the period of life until one receives citizenship (8 years).

    “The Excecutioner.

    A large figure in white robe stained with dirt and blood. His head is covered in Ku Klux Klan cone-like hood with openings for eyes – except for there are no eyes in the openings, just darkness. He holds a large gavel which can smash you in one move. Very dangerous. He can somehow influence the walls, floors, and ceilings and move them to make me trapped. I don’t think there is any humanity left in those authority people who deport, punish, send to death.” – Ruslan

    “It is a creature representing Migri workers. It is an exact replica of a dream I had during a period of intense anxiety about my husband’s and my residency situation in Finland. The creature is tall, has a single white eye that tracks everyone, and comes to live with you throughout your eight years in Finland.” – Huseyin

    Finnish authorities continue insecurity and indignity that forced migrants who erroneously hoped to escape, or as Anatoly put it: “the status (marriage) seemed more pleasant, you know? Who knew I’d be so wrong.“

    However, not only public officials become terrifying. Instead of being cared by the state that would assess their need for safety, forced migrants become dependent on the good will of random people in Finland.

    “Migri didn’t protect me directly, in fact I felt like I was applying for an asylum to an employer. <…> The only reason things are kind of okay for me is my very patient spouse, who kindly agreed to stay married until I get permanent residency.“ – Anatoly

    As these people are not obliged to provide any security by law and it’s not even their duty, they may disrespect a forced migrant’s situation and harm them. Moreover, with racism and other stereotypes, Finnish society makes life even further more insecure and unpredictable.

    “I had three employers – one understanding, one indifferent, one just the worst of all. <…> Before I trusted my co-workers and bosses in healthcare – until I got bullied by physicians and nurses after I started expressing how immigration laws in Finland are bad and inhumane and how everyone is just ignorant.” – Ruslan

    “One of the things that hurt me the most at that time was hearing that some of my husband’s Finnish coworkers criticized him, saying things like ‘Why is he still in such a relationship?’ That kind of comment felt extremely cruel.“ – Huseyin

    Unsplash/Tim Gouw

    Ruslan further writes on how citizens in Finland and authorities can be connected, while he is disconnected from both:

    “One time I got a message from Migri about something and I needed something from my employer. I got shocked when I heard that a secretary called my residence permit decision maker in Migri to ask for my situation. It was so easy for them to contact them, and almost impossible for me.”

    Anatoly writes about other struggles:

    “I’m fully aware of the power imbalance — that any mistake I make could easily end in a divorce, and that would be a major loss for me. <…> There was psychological abuse, and financial abuse too. [My spouse] sometimes threatened me with divorce as blackmail. <…> It was always the same pattern: “Do what I want, or I’ll divorce you.” ”

    Ruslan also symbolically showed this hostility, lack of understanding, and the ease of cooperation between officials and Finnish citizens in his picture he made and enhanced with AI. Just like Huseyin, in this his picture hints to surveillance leading to threats of bureaucratic violence from the Finnish authorities is clearly seen. The disconnection and detachment from co-workers is seen in how Ruslan named the creatures – aliens.

    Aliens. “Some childlike humanoid creatures with big emotionless faces with glowing eyes. I should avoid them. Once they notice me they point their fingers at me summoning their authority, the Excecutioner. Most people here make me sick.”

    Because the Finnish authorities “delegated” care for forced migrants’ security to Anatoly’s spouse and Ruslan’s working circles, neither Anatoly nor Ruslan felt they can leave such people – together with them, they’d lose their security even more as they’d get deported from Finland. So, they got trapped and forced to endure their life conditions.

    Anatoly’s spouse refused to accept Anatoly’s transgender identity controlling Anatoly into playing a female role:

    “Not directly, but in a subtle “I need a pretty girl, or else I’ll…” kind of way. And the thing is, [my spouse] knew perfectly well from the start that I wasn’t cisgender. I didn’t really have a choice — I just clenched my teeth and went along with it, playing the “girl in dresses” role. <…> I couldn’t live the way I wanted — it’s not just about clothes. The very fact that people see me as a woman is, let’s say, deeply unpleasant to me.”

    In addition, Anatoly felt that he had to deny himself trans care:

    “I don’t have access to gender-affirming healthcare — and honestly, [my spouse’s] presence is one of the reasons I haven’t started it yet”

    Anatoly emphasized that this life situation isn’t really his choice:

    “If it weren’t for all this paperwork and status stuff, we’d have happily gone our separate ways years ago.”

    Ruslan got mobbed at work which was the basis of his and, indirectly, his husband’s residence permits. “When I was mobbed I couldn’t change my jobs because I was waiting for my family reunification and I was forced to be very cautious all the time. You can’t leave one job if you don’t have another already.”

    Even though Ruslan mentioned the dependency on employers only, one can imagine the situation of mobbing:

    “I go to a job interview or just to a meeting where they’ll be and my hands are shaking and everything squeezes inside. And I think, what will I do if they don’t like me? If they don’t prolong a contract? I also needed my family reunification and it always depended on work contract too – too short and Huseyin wouldn’t be able to come. I had always ask for a longer contract.” – Ruslan

    Unfreedom and hurting conditions eventually harm forced migrants even further – mentally, and this further compromises their ability to secure their lives in Finland. Anatoly and Ruslan described this kind of harm.

    Mobbed co-workers eventually made Ruslan burn out:

    “I got burned out at work a lot – couldn’t focus much on anything medical, felt depressed and useless plus nurses were always unfriendly to migrant physicians including me – I just couldn’t continue doing that job. I felt that if I do, then I’ll fuck my mental health – and when it happens, goodbye my permit. <…>You just think “be whatever will be”. I’m tired of struggles.”

    Anatoly, unable to escape physically from his spouse‘s abuse, developed a way to escape from it mentally – dissociations:

    “Most of the time I just dissociate <…> like, “that’s not really happening to me, so whatever.” Honestly, there are a couple of years I don’t even remember. I can piece together the timeline from photos, but I have zero memories.”

    Unsplash/Hannah Xu

    This forced dependancy and inability to leave even when a forced migrant feels exhausted is reflected in Ruslan’s picture who he named “the Slave“.

    “A naked cachectic exhausted body hanging in space whose arms and legs are attached to some constantly moving levels. Endless torment. It is trapped and has no will of its own. Its mouth and nose are closed with a wooden bar and so are its eyes. How long will I be trapped in bureaucracy, forced to do things I don’t want, reject my wishes and dignity?“

    Anatoly, Ruslan, and Huseyin told Borderlines that typical welfare assistance – such as psychological counseling or social work – are not made for their wellbeing. Because it’s the state itself that harms and frightens them, they cannot trust the services that are again offered by the state. As critical social scientists outline, marginalized people’s suspicion toward the ways such institutions work is reasonable (Foucault, 1961/1965; Fanon, 1965; Metzl, 2010; Cantu et al., 2024)

    “Before that [getting mobbed at the workplace] happened, I told others [coworkers] about my situation in hope they’ll somehow help – I couldn’t bring my husband here. One physician told a social worker – but she just said there’s nothing she can do, and offered a psychologist – as if a public psychologist could convince Migri in something. It’s really interesting how firstly the state deeply hurts you and then they offer you a psychologist to get used to the hurting. F*ck no – I thought – I know where it’s going. I need help with this f*cking sh*t that Finland made – not the way to get used to it or change how I feel or what I think about it.” – Ruslan

    Borderlines interviewer: Tell me — has a psychologist, doctor, or social worker helped you at all with this situation, with your husband and migrant status?

    Anatoly: – No, even though I see my psych team regularly — more often than I see anyone else, actually. Only when I switched municipalities they assigned some social workers after we said the relationship was complicated. But it’s not in my best interest to make this story public with the authorities — it’s risky for me.

    – Yeah, I understand. Are you afraid they might revoke your residence permit?

    – Yeah, or that my spouse will find out and tell me to get lost.

    Anatoly sums up what the Finnish state does to forced migrants in his artistic text. This picture clearly contradicts Finland as a country of human rights and promised dignity and equality for all. Throguht his text there is an atmosphere of abandonedness, unfreedom, and aloneness combined with exhausting struggles with the state that, as Ruslan put it, “makes you weak, they want you undocumented and out – and they don’t care what’ll happen to you.“

    “It’s chilly; the air smells of dust and cold, and faintly—barely perceptibly—of smoke: both from burning tires and from the peat. The morning sun—though in winter it comes by noon—is glimmering through the low clouds on the horizon. A very, very fine clean road stretches that way, four lanes wide, surrounded by harvested wheat fields, dusted here and there with snow. Beyond them, a forest can be seen, but very far away.

    The wind is whistling, and the snow is crunching underfoot. And that’s all. Well, except for the sound of fabric rubbing against fabric with a vile creak. He has no face, no home, and no way back. The shroud gives no warmth, his feet are raw, and he would gladly stop a car, hitch a ride anywhere at all—only there are no cars here.

    Where the road leads is unclear, too. The signs lie, there’s no one to ask, hope fades that there’s anything at all out there—but what else can he do, if not go on?”

    What to do?

    As Anatoly, Ruslan and Huseyin’s stories illustrate, migrants rarely fit the administrative categories of asylum seeker, worker, student and family member, or the binary of forced migrant vs. voluntary migrant. Though these categories do not reflect the realities of migrants, they are used both by the Finnish government and civil society when shaping migration policy and services.

    Ruslan describes how he has been excluded both from worker migrant and refugee activism when seeking help:

    “I come to worker migrant groups and they say “it’s not to us, go to refugee circles”. I come to refugee circles and they say “we’re protecting only asylum rights, go to worker migrants”. <…> I also was among refugee rights activists but whenever I tried to bring my situation ti then or the situation of people like me it was either some awkward silence or the same reaxtion – we dont care, asylum is already too hard we dont have time for people like you. I feel betrayed. If they decided to struggle for justice, how can they say such things? <…> With other activists and migrants I feel lonely – because my situation is different. I just accepted this – you have to live with this sense of being misunderstood and exclusion.“

    Huseyin describes the Finnish state and its systems as very bureaucratic and lacking emotion and empathy: “I don’t think Finland truly understands our real reason for being here.” This same lack of understanding and recognition of a migrant’s humanity is portrayed in Anatoly’s artistic text. The text portrays him alone in a cold unwelcoming landscape stripped of his personhood, past, and future.

    “Asylum seekers’ rights are human rights. Treat them humanely. <…> Ideally, everyone should have equal rights.” – Anatoly

    According to the Finnish Constitution, everyone is entitled to fundamental rights, including personal freedom, integrity, and safety (FinLex, 1999). The human rights, such as freedom and equality of all people, freedom from torture, gender and racial equality and economic, social, cultural, political and civic rights, are laid down in the international conventions, which Finland has signed (Ulkoministeriö, n.d.). As outlined above, the recent trend of tightening legislation and bureaucratic practices concerning migration and asylum puts people on the move in situations where their fundamental and human rights cannot be guaranteed.

    On the state level, changes in legislation and practices of authorities such as Migri and the Border Force are needed. Support for Asylum Seekers (Turvapaikanhakijoiden tuki ry, 2026) and the Finnish Refugee Advise Centre, together with other human rights organizations, have drafted a list of proposals to be included in the government program in 2027.

    Proposals include, among others:

    • The full implementation of the recommendations given to Finland by the European and UN councils. The recommendations cover such themes as the eradication of racism and discrimination, and the unsatisfactory legal rights of asylum seekers.
    • The government should deconstruct structural racism through intersectional legislation and change the strict laws concerning migrants and asylum seekers to a more human rights based legislation.
    • The right to seek asylum must be protected in practice in all situations and asylum seeking women should be seen as a particularly vulnerable group.
    • NGOs should be supported by public funding in a sustainable and predictable manner. They should be recognized as an important part of Finnish society for their work toward inclusion, democracy, and equality.

    An example of a more human rights based legislation could be the reinstation of Humanitarian Protection or expanding the definion of a refugee following the example of Cartagena Declaration and the OAU Refugee Convention. It would also involve repealing the recent changes in the law made by Orpo’s government, such as the “pushback” and “pathway change” preventing laws. A more intersectional approach to legislation would recognize, for example, the fact that queer couples do not always have the same chances to live together prior to applying for a family based permit.

    Sustainable funding for NGO’s would guarantee the service provision in a steadily worsening unemployment situation that together with the tightening restrictions to work based and resisdence permits threathens to make people undocumented.

    Alongside state and municipality funded NGO’s the Finnish society needs groups and networks who are not financially dependent on the authorities and can critize them without having to worry about losing their funding:

    “[T]here is no this partisan wish to help you – help find employers, maybe offer employers, direct[ly] condemn Migri in the talk and show whose side they are on, and most important – offer some real help and do something and not just do talking!” – Ruslan

    Ruslan’s idea is that we should shift from consultation and support based on rigid bureaucratic categories toward a more community based support system. To address the actual needs of people on the move we need to form networks of people willing to act:

    “We need employers who are ready to take people in such a way that Migri accepts. That would be some real help. Everything else feels just more like pretending to help than helping, unfortunately… <…> Activists should make a pool of employers who would be able to take to work those in urgent need – those who are at risk of becoming undocumented.” – Ruslan

    The borders work through fixing, categorizing and setting people in new relations of power. To actively deconsrtuct these hierarchies and work towards equal rights for all, we need to resist this divise logic in our work and communities (Vapaa Liikkuvuus, 2009; Anderson et al., 2009; Roohi et al., 2025).

    Since the early 2000’s the UN Refugee Agency (UNCHR) and International Organization for Migration (IOM) have based their immigration policy recommendations and service provision on the understanding that migration is mixed. Mixed migration refers both to the mixed motivations of the people on the move and the fact that people with different reasons for leaving move through the same channels of migration. This can refer to the physical paths over the borders or the fact that, as in the case of Anatoly, Huseyin and Ruslan, both forced and voluntary migrants utilize the same bureaucratic means to obtain permits. (International Organization for Migration, n.d.; The Migration Observatory, 2011; The UN Refugee Agency, n.d.)

    The tendency to categorize people on the move as “refugees” and “migrants” overlooks the fact that people might have multiple and changing motivations for migrating. Instead of bureaucratical categories at the destination, the focus should be on reasons of emigration from a source country and on understanding forced and voluntary migration as life situations and not as identities. Forced and voluntary migration should be understood as a spectrum and the place on that spectrum might change during a person’s journey if, for example, the conditions in the source country change.

    As illustrated by the stories of Ruslan, Huseyin and Anatolyi, when asylum is outsourced, family and work permits can hide a real need for safety. Examples of non-asylum forced migration are:

    • a person flees danger but decides to chose a way alternative to asylum, as in Ruslan and Anatoly’s cases
    • the situation in a person’s country of citizenship becomes riskier while they are in Finland as in the case of Huseyin
    • the person was politically silent while in the country of citizenship, but becomes politically active in Finland, which makes return dangerous

    Naim Panahi was granted asylum after four year long process. He was originally denied asylum after Migri determined his age as 18, in contrast to the age of 16 based on the information given to Naim by his parents. After Naim appealed the decision, he was granted asylum based on the fact he had become politically active and “more western” while in Finland and it was not safe for him to return. (Töyrylä, 2023)

    • a person whose asylum aplication was rejected and they applied for a residence permit based on studies, or work or family

    After 2022 around 1000 people from Russia have applied for asylum based on the fact that they are escaping conscription to an army that is committing war crimes. As Migri currently does not grant asylum for people based on the threat that they could be conscripted to Russian army, around one third of the applicants found ways to stay on study or work based residence permits. (Trifonov, n.d.)

    Categories like “economic migrant”, “refugee”, “worker”, and “student” are ways to control migration and their usefulness for emancipation should be questioned. People’s lives do not fit into a single box and the language we use in activism and advocacy should be inclusive for all. We all hold multiple identities and our life situations are everchanging. The priviledge of not having your life flattened to a single category should not be only afforded to some.

    In order to give and find appropriate help and to move towards a more humane immigration policy the full humanity of people on the move needs to be seen and respected. Everyone is entitled to safety and on bureacratical level each case deserves careful consideration instead of expedited asylum processes or violent push backs.

    (originally published: February 17, 2026)

    How to cite this article (APA style)

    Borderlines. (2026, June 11). Outsourced asylum. https://borderlinesfi.blog/en/2026/06/11/outsourced-asylum/ (Accessed: your date)

    References
  • Finland’s Aliens Act and several related laws have been significantly amended in recent years. Researchers, jurists, NGOs, and other experts have criticised the changes and warned that they would weaken the rights of immigrants (Yhdenvertaisuusvaltuutettu, 2024; Advokaatti, 2025; Talentia, 2025; Pakolaisneuvonta, 2024).

    There are also changes being added to the Citizenship Act now:

    • In the future, a citizenship applicant must not have relied on unemployment benefits or social assistance for more than three months within the last two years.
    • In addition, criminal offences will make obtaining citizenship more difficult than before.
    • Citizenship can also be lost more easily if a person has given false information or otherwise acted fraudulently during the citizenship application process (Maahanmuuttovirasto, 2025).

    We examined parliamentary debates relating to the amendment of the Nationality Act (Government Proposal HE 19/2024 vp) as well as comments under related news articles (Ilta-Sanomat, 2025; Helsingin Sanomat, 2025). The most-liked comments (with at least 20% of the likes of the most popular comment) were collected from two widely read Finnish online newspapers that had reported on the reform. Both parliamentary debates on the government proposal were also included as material. The aim was to understand how people who have moved to Finland are spoken about in discussions concerning the Nationality Act.

    In the news comments and in parliamentary debates, immigration is presented as an unquestioned burden on Finland’s economy. This way of speaking is typical of Finnish immigration policy, but especially in the rhetoric ofthe Finns Party: economic usefulness is used as a means to alienate certain ethnic groups and to maintain white nationalism (Keskinen, 2016; 2023).

    In the comments, people who have immigrated are described as “living off others,” exploiting Finland’s social security system:

    “The direction is right now. We’ll get Finland working, without people living off others.”

    “<…> Quite simply, if you can receive several thousand euros in benefits for doing nothing, then of course you’re not interested in applying for work when you get more by doing nothing (this is how people end up settling into the lobby of Kela).”

    Well said (219)

    (ibid.)

    “<…> Things haven’t been called by their real names, and now the costs of immigration and shopping around for social benefits are being revealed in all their horror, as these issues are finally starting to come to light. <…>”

    Well said (87)

    (ibid.)

    Terms like “living off others,” “shopping around for social benefits,” and “milking the system” evoke images of laziness and dishonesty. They appeal to feelings of injustice: it is not fair that you work and pay taxes if someone else “spends the day idling at home” (Government Proposal HE 19/2025 vp, first reading) on your money.

    In parliamentary speeches, politicians also invoke such feelings of injustice and respond to them by presenting themselves as defenders of “the Finnish taxpayer”.

    In this framing, Finns are depicted as conscientious taxpayers, and immigrants as exploiters who aim—deliberately and even deceitfully—to take advantage of the system.

    “The income requirement is fair and necessary. Citizenship can no longer be built on social security. Above all, this is fair to Finnish taxpayers, who keep this country running every single day.” — Jaana Strandman (Finns Party), GP 19/2025, first reading, 7 Oct., 03:19:55

    “— (I)s the problem perhaps that one can no longer come across the Mediterranean in a rubber boat, throw their passport into the sea, claim they cannot assist the immigration authorities in determining their identity, and still obtain Finnish citizenship once enough time has passed?” — Miko Bergbom (Finns Party), GP 19/2025, second reading, 14 Oct., 02:28:46

    “— People lean on welfare instead of working and aim for Finnish citizens, to pay for their living for their entire life(.)” — Mauri Peltokangas (Finns Party), GP 19/2025, first reading, 7 Oct., 04:07:14

    The motif of “throwing the passport into the sea” recurs throughout the discussions, sustaining an image of fraud. These stories also create a distorted understanding of what the journey to Europe can actually be: more than 33,000 people have died or gone missing in the Mediterranean since 2014 (IOM, 2025).

    The image of deceit is also reinforced by the idea that unemployment and receiving social security are seen as personal choices: people are described as “aiming for Finnish citizens to pay for your living.” In reality, finding employment in Finland is shaped by significant structural barriers and discrimination (Akhlaq, 2025) — and in fact, the social security received during the initial integration phase makes it easier to find work later on (STM, 2020).

    Finland’s poor economic situation is brought up frequently in the discussions. Immigrants are blamed for the country’s economic problems, and immigration is portrayed as something the economy cannot endure:

    The economic impact of immigration is described in terms of “ruin,” even though wealthy states benefit greatly from, and are dependent on, foreign labour — and on the exploitation of those workers (Teittinen, 2025; see also Borderlines: Immigration and work)

    There is also published evidence that in Finland people whose mother tongue is a foreign language pay more in taxes than they receive in benefits, and that the net impact of immigration on the public sector is positive (Myrskylä & Kainulainen, 2025; ETLA, 2024). Despite this, the negative economic impact of immigration is treated as self-evident, and legislative changes are therefore seen as a “completely necessary decision.”

    In these discussions about immigration’s economic effects, there is also no questioning of the assumption that it’s economic usefulness of a person that should determine their value or their rights.

    As the opposite of a “person living off others,” the discussions construct an image of the hard-working immigrant who is “genuinely integrated” and therefore “deserves” Finnish citizenship. In debates on citizenship, immigrants are expected to “earn” their place in Finnish society under almost unreasonable conditions which are defined externally without taking the migrants’ own circumstances into account.

    “Finnish citizenship should be earned only through a story of development: eight years of blameless and crime-free life, a livelihood earned through work without alms from society, learning the national language, and adapting to the local customs. To a good candidate for naturalisation I extend my hand, regardless of skin colour or religion.” — Teemu Keskisarja (Finns Party), GP 19/2025, first reading, 7 Oct., 03:49:19

    “Citizenship must be based on the applicant genuinely demonstrating their integration into Finnish society, customs, language, laws, culture, and the Finnish way of life, which includes our history, traditions, celebrations, and food.” — Jaana Strandman (Finns Party), GP 19/2025, first reading, 7 Oct., 04:29:05

    The discussions offer various definitions of successful integration, but what unites them is the reinforcement of nationalist myths about the Finnish nation-state. Expressions such as “local customs” and “the Finnish way of life” construct an image of Finland as a homogeneous state whose people share a common language, values, and traditions. What remains hidden is that Finland has never had just one culture or language.

    Indigenous people, as well as linguistic and cultural minorities, are sidelined in this way of speaking. They do not fit into the idea of “us,” the unified Finnish people — an idea that has been central to the construction of the Finnish nation-state. The myth of a unified nation maintains ethnic and racialised inequalities and hierarchies, for example in determining who is seen as deserving of the welfare state and its social security (Toivanen & Keskinen, 2020).

    “The tightening of this government’s immigration policy is now changing the uncontrolled and lax immigration we have had until now. A good thing, because we certainly do not want to head towards Sweden’s situation, where crime and violence, drug-related crime, gang formation, and armed violence are everyday realities.” — Merja Rasinkangas (Finns Party), GP 19/2025, first reading, 7 Oct., 04:46:19

    In addition to the economy, security is strongly emphasised, especially in the parliamentary debates. When security is discussed, migrants are portrayed as potential criminals and security threats, and therefore their rights and opportunities must be restricted.

    The tightening of immigration policy is presented as necessary for preventing crime. In the parliamentary discussions on the nationality act, speakers even refer to terrorism and serial killers. Such extreme examples evoke fear and insecurity, positioning politicians as protectors of Finland’s safety when they tighten laws:

    “We, Finns Party members, spoke a lot before the elections about tightening immigration policy, and this is exactly what we have done and will continue to do, because national security is important to us.” — Anne Rintamäki (Finns Party), GP 19/2025, first reading, 7 Oct., 03:25:25

    The connection between immigration and security is presented in the speeches as self-evident. Talking about immigration as a security threat (so-called securitisation) has been a major part of European migration policy over recent decades. It restricts migrants’ movement and lives, but brings both economic and political benefits to European states.

    Security is used to justify limiting migrants’ rights, deportations, and larger budgets for border control and the security sector. A profitable industry has grown around the “securitisation” of migration—one that benefits from restricting people’s movement and their conditions of living (Anderson, 2014).

    In the era of globalisation, labelling migrants as a threat is also a way for politicians to protect the independence of the nation-state and to divert attention from domestic political problems (Kalir, 2022).

    Some actors in Finland have pointed out that it is actually the current government’s cuts to social security and NGO funding that undermine national security (Naisjärjestöjen keskusliitto, 2024; RETS, 2024).

    In the discussions related to the Nationality Act that we examined, there are clear assumptions that immigrants may lie, commit crimes, or exploit Finland’s system economically.

    Distrust and negative images of migrants are deliberately constructed through terms such as “people living off others” and by evoking emotions like injustice and fear. With these means, Finns Party politicians in particular justify tightening immigration policy, present themselves as protectors of the people, and shift attention away from domestic political issues.

    Nämä mielikuvat myös palvelevat niiden poliittisia agendoja, kuten valkoista nationalismia. EThese images also serve their political agendas, such as white nationalism. Although representatives from the Left Alliance and the Greens did voice opposing views, 38 of the 50 speeches in the first and second readings came from the Finns Party. People have also adopted the rhetoric of the Finns Party, as seen in the comment sections of Ilta-Sanomat and Helsingin Sanomat. Stories about “shopping on social security” and “passports thrown into the sea” are told without ever hearing migrants’ own stories.

    Most people, regardless of background, want to work and live a good life. Immigration policy and legislation, however, are built on a cynical and unfair image of the very people whose lives they affect the most. After analysing the political rhetoric and comments, we can question the legislative changes that rely on an incorrect, negative, and threat-focused portrayal of immigration.

    For the sake of security and Finland’s economy—but especially to prevent structural violence—immigration policy and legislation should be based on trust. By highlighting migrants’ own goals and their significant contribution to society, legislation could further support the realisation of these goals.

    (originally published: December 12, 2025)

    How to cite this article (APA style)
    References

  • Finland: Homophobic gay Paradise

    Finland is known as a country that respects the equality of the queer community. According to ILGA-Europe, Finland ranked fourth-best in Europefor gay-friendly laws and policies.

    “According to Finnish law, everyone is entitled to be treated equally regardless of their background, gender or other characteristics. <…> Equality (yhdenvertaisuus) means that all people are equal regardless of their age, ethnic or national origin, nationality, language, religion or beliefs, opinion, disability, health, sexual orientation or any other circumstance connected to the person.” — InfoFinland. (n.d.). Equality and non‑discrimination

    “…everyone in Finland can trust that their rights and the principles of gender equality, equality before the law and non-discrimination will be respected and that they will be able to improve their own lives” — Finnish Government. (2023). Government statement to Parliament on promoting equality, gender equality and non-discrimination in Finnish society.

    But do Finnish laws really embrace equality and treat all people with equal respect? Can all same-sex couples marry and start a family in Finland?

    Stories of some same-sex families who moved to Finland show a different reality. For example, Huseyin and Ruslan’s story reveals that, just like in the “uncivilized” countries they came from, Finnish laws still block some same-sex couples from marrying and starting a family — simply because they are a same-sex couple. This challenges the idea that Finland is fully “gay-friendly” and treats all same-sex families equally.

    Important: Ruslan and Huseyin told Borderlines that they had written Amnesty International and the Free Movement network about their case. Amnesty verified that this was a violation of the right to family. Free Movement verified that the obstacle to marry in Finland was true.

    On the next images, you will see the family story of Huseyin, a citizen of Turkey, and Ruslan, a Russian citizen, as told by them.

    If official Finnish sources claim that LGBTQ+ people are equal to straight people, why do Finnish laws create so many obstacles for Huseyin and Ruslan?

    The struggles they faced happened simply because they are a gay couple from homophobic countries.

    Heterosexism is belief that only relationships between a man and a woman are valuable or “normal,” while relationships between two men or two women are seen as less valuable, “wrong,” or “broken.” Heterosexism isn’t just personal prejudice — it’s also built into laws and institutions (Herek, 1990; Kolehmainen et al., 2023). Historically, straight couples were allowed to be married while same-sex families were denied that right (Cortina & Festy, 2020).

    Most of the countries still don’t allow same-sex marriage. Heterosexism from other countries also affects the rights of same-sex couples who move to Finland. Finnish laws about migrants are also shaped by these biases, so same-sex couples face discrimination both in their home countries and in Finland, their new home (Homanen & Alastalo, 2024).

    Russia and Turkey deny same-sex couples to get married. Ruslan described what happened when he called the Digital and Population Data Services Agency (DVV) to ask whether he could get married in Finland:

    “Then I called DVV and asked a worker if we could get married, because on the official page, it states “If neither spouse is a Finnish citizen or lives in Finland, they must … submit to the Digital and Population Data Services Agency a clarification on whether the legislation in their home country allows them to get married in Finland.” I asked about this, and the worker said it means exactly what I understood. And when I asked what to do, she just said, “wait for 5 years until you get citizenship then you can get married.” I was shocked with how condescending and hypocritical that sounded.”

    Here, the DVV worker was most likely mistaken and advised wrongly – a same-sex couple of migrants can get married as soon as they get a type A permit. This could have taken less than 5 years at that time. Nevertheless, this illustrates how DVV workers can sometimes be incompetent in handling same-sex couples’ cases.

    It clearly shows how Finnish laws can block migrant same-sex couples from getting the rights LGBTQ+ citizens of Finland have. This is an example of heterosexism at the structural level (laws and bureaucracy).

    In Finland, heterosexism also hides in the Marriage Act:

    In practice, this law discriminates same-sex couples who are not citizens of Finland or doesn’t hold a certain residence permit.

    You might wonder: why does heterosexism still exist in Finland? Finnish citizens can marry freely regardless of the partners’ genders . So why can’t migrants like Huseyin and Ruslan?

    The difference comes from certain beliefs in Finland. Homonationalism is when some people believe that their nation’s protection of LGBTQ+ rights as proof that it is modern, progressive, and morally superior. In contrast, countries where such rights are not protected are viewed as “backward” or “bad.” As a result, discriminating laws and policies against migrants from supposedly “homophobic” countries, including queer ones, are considered justified (Puar, 2007; 2013; El-Tayeb, 2011; Lugones, 2023).

    Homonationalism can be found both in laws and society. Ruslan accuses Finnish society in general:

    “…they [people in Finland] only care about Finnish people or those whose same-sex marriage is allowed. Finnish gay couples can marry without a problem, but not migrants. And those queer migrants who can marry in their home countries can marry in Finland too – but not us. This is nothing else but a betrayal.”

    Huseyin blames Finnish activists:

    “We contacted many organizations, such as Seta and Amnesty to get support, but no authority really acknowledged or supported our relationship during that time. Seta told us that they only deal with situations happening inside Finland and that they couldn’t help us, even though our case was clearly connected to Finland. It felt like we were treated as if our relationship didn’t matter, like strangers, not as a real couple trying to build a life together.”

    Some people forget that there are queer people living in the countries they call “homophobic” or “bad”. Thus, some feel okay with unfair laws, such as blocking same-sex marriage for migrants, out of fear that “foreigners” might fake being a gay couple to enter Europe. These laws protect Finland’s political image and diplomatic interests, instead of insuring safety and dignity of non-European same-sex couples. Such policy clearly goes against Finland’s own promise that everyone should be treated equally, no matter their background, gender, or sexual orientation.

    Since the part of the Marriage Act that governs non-citizens of Finland isn’t apllied to Finnish same-sex couples, the law discriminates only LGBTQ+ migrants, but not LGBTQ+ Finnish citizens.

    Non-European LGBTQ+ people often get less recognition, fewer rights, and face more problems in Finland than their European peers. This is connected to European colonial history and has been studied by sociologist Aníbal Quijano (2007).

    Coloniality of power means that even after colonialism officially ended, the ways Europeans organised power, knowledge, and social hierarchies still shape the modern world. It’s the ongoing influence of colonialism: some people — especially white, European, Western people — are still seen as more “advanced” or “civilized,” and they get to decide what happens to others, whom they see as people “worse” than “us”.

    “We got to know that Portugal and Denmark can register your marriage even if you are not a citizen or a migrant with a residence permit. I wrote one Danish service, but they answered: “Technically, we are happy to make you married, but Denmark doesn’t let you in, especially if they know you’re coming here to marry”. We felt trapped and completely crushed.” — Ruslan

    Ruslan meant that Denmark wouldn’t give a visa to his partner so that they could marry there.

    Visa policies show coloniality of power. They rank countries — and the people in them — based on ideas of safety, trust, or “civilization,” echoing old colonial hierarchies. Since these policies are made by people, they reflect how some of them think about others: there are those who “deserve” to come to Europe or the EU easily, and who don’t (van Houtum, 2022).

    (van Houtum & Lacy, 2020)

    Huseyin and Ruslan’s struggles aren’t just paperwork problems — their case shows a system that prefers European queer people and excludes non-European ones. Visa rules, embassy practices, and marriage recognition laws prioritise Western, “desirable” queers and block LGBTQ+ people from non-European or “homophobic” countries. Despite official claims, Finland does not treat all queer people equally — its laws remain homophobic toward some migrant LGBTQ+ couples.

    Huseyin and Ruslan’s struggles aren’t just paperwork problems — their case shows a system that prefers European queer people and excludes non-European ones. Visa rules, embassy practices, and marriage recognition laws prioritise Western, “desirable” queers and block LGBTQ+ people from non-European or “homophobic” countries. Despite official claims, Finland does not treat all queer people equally — its laws remain homophobic toward some migrant LGBTQ+ couples.

    Living with a broken promise

    Some people in Finland trick people abroad into coming to Finland by promising something valuable, often money. But those promises are broken when the person comes to Finland, and instead they find their life is being controlled by the person who invited them here This is called human trafficking, and in Finland it’s punished according to Chapter 25 of the Criminal Code.

    But as sociologist Sara Ahmed (2004; 2012) writes, states can also trick people with false promises. Ahmed explains that this happens when a state wants to show people how “good” it is – for example, in terms of diversity. When this “branding” is the main goal and no real change happens, people get tricked by the false hope that they will become equal and included.

    Finland lures queer people living in bad and dangerous conditions in other countries by promising them the “liberal freedom” to be themselves. But this can be a false, homonationalist promise.

    In other words, the state promises queer freedom only to its citizens or people living in the West – but not others. In following their dream of freedom, other queer people get trapped, betrayed, and hurt.

    The story of Ruslan and Huseyin (names changed) – and many other queer couples who faced similar problems – started not in Finland, but abroad, in Russia, Turkey, Kazakhstan or other “homophobic” countries. They looked longingly towards Finland and another “gay-friendly” countries from the outside.

    Ruslan described his life in Russia:

    “In Russia having a same-sex family is dangerous and scary. Anyone can beat you, call the police, police can beat you or imprison you. Even if you didn’t do anything – they’ll make something up. They bring illicit drugs and claim that they got them from you. They demand money and threaten that if you don’t give they’ll tell others about you. But now after the war started and they adopted many other laws, it’s just illegal to be seen as a gay couple – they’ll claim you’re spreading terrorism. You will be imprisoned for that and die in the prison because there they’ll kill you for being gay. And then there are nationalist and far-right activists and they deliberately search for lgbtq people and beat them, record their beatings”

    Huseyin echoed Ruslan’s fear:

    “Only two of my friends knew about my relationship. I definitely didn’t feel safe being open about it. My relatives are very conservative, and they only found out about my situation after I moved to Finland. If I had still been in my home country, I’m certain I would have faced violence and strong family pressure. They would have tried to force me to marry a woman because, in their eyes, my relationship would bring them ‘shame’ if others found out.”

    In our post about queer asylum seekers from Russia, Borderlines wrote about how queer people in the post-Soviet countires feel constant unsease, a “climate of hate” which means that anyone – a relative, a police officer, a neighbor – can turn violent against you (Novitskaya, 2023). Researchers and NGOs show that this is true not only for post-Soviet countries, but also Turkiye, parts of Africa, and parts of Asia (see the section “the climate of hate towards LGBTQ+ people” in References).

    When Ruslan looked abroad, he noticed Finland in the media and on websites related to LGBTQ+ rights and migration.

    In 2022, the government coalition was led by Sanna Marin, who also visited Pride. Every year, Helsinki Pride turns Helsinki into a colorful festival, with politicians, authorities, companies, and NGOs showing how they support queer people’s right to be equal. Official statements from the government and public services also claimed that LGBTQ people will be treated with dignity.

    Ruslan describes the image of Finland that he saw on the Internet and heard about from others:

    “I moved first. I had a medical diploma, and I thought it would be easier to move through work. I also imagined Finland as an example of equality and justice, and I wanted to bring both my husband and my parents here. I imagined that if I told people about my life they would empathize and accept me without questions – especially because I myself shared the ideals of human rights and equality. <…> “I thought that Finland would of course allow us to marry – because where else can we do that? We are victims in Russia and Turkey, and Finland as a country of democracy, human dignity, and justice would understand and offer marriage to people like us. And we would have the same rights as anyone else here – both queer and straight couples.“

    Many other queer migrants have similar hopes when they move away from dangerous countries. They see how Finland, or the US, as you’ll see next, are painted in “gay-friendly” and “liberal” tones, how LGBTQ+ people are free there, and they start to hope that they will get that freedom, too. Sociologist Alexandra Novitskaya interviewed several queer people who came to the US from post-Soviet countries (2025). Tata, from Russia, simply said that: “I have come to this country to be happy.”

    She explained:

    “There’s this American Dream and all that. I hope that my American Dream will come true soon too. <…> I started thinking about the future, about how and where I would like to grow old. After all, despite my sexuality, I would like to have kids. I started thinking of how I could make it happen. In Russia, I never had thoughts like this. I only thought about surviving.”

    Another queer migrant, Karina, from Kazakhstan, echoed Tata:

    “I like, for example, that everything here is permeated, America is permeated, first, with the air of freedom, in every meaning of this word, yes, freedom, and it is permeated with some air of the American Dream. <…> But for me, moving to America was never for economic reasons. <…> But it is precisely to be who you are, and not try to crawl back in the closet. This is kind of an ideal country for that. And I also like that every, absolutely every movement regarding some, well, opportunities, of going beyond stereotypes or labels was born precisely in America. Starting with feminism, and LGBTQ rights, to even this idea of queer. All these meanings and attempts to destigmatize, to go beyond a label forced upon you, this is where it all began.”

    With such an image of Finland that Ruslan found on the Internet and heard about from others, Ruslan “expected that before marriage, Huseyin would be able to come here, to the maximum of days allowed as I visited Turkey. I imagined it like this: Huseyin will come as my partner and we will marry here, and then he’ll apply for a family-based residence permit.”

    Huseyin wrote:

    “Before marriage, we first wanted to live together as a couple in Finland, but the Finnish authorities required us to have lived together abroad for at least one year. We didn’t meet this requirement because my husband was living in Russia, and when we met, it was just before he moved to Finland. This rule felt strange and unfair to us.”

    Importantly, Russia doesn’t allow Turkish citizens to enter its territory without a visa, and the homophobic climate of hate puts queer couples under threat (Embassy of the Russian Federation in Malaysia, n.d.). Conversely, Turkey allows Russian citizens to stay in the country without a visa, but only for 60 days per visit and for 90 days in total within half a year (Republic of Türkiye, Ministry of Foreign Affairs, n.d.). This prevented Ruslan and Huseyin from living together continuosuly.

    After Ruslan came here, the couple faced a different, absurd reality hidden behind the “gay-friendly” and “liberal” branding. A state that claimed to protect LGBTQ+ rights restricted their family life. A state that claimed to value “the family” created barriers to forming one. The bureaucracy demanded proof of love, then rejected the proof as insufficient. The couple ran into obstacles, which made them doubt whether Finland really is the way it appears from outside. Even though Ruslan was in Finland, he and Huseyin faced more and more obstacles as time passed. In order to reunite as a family, the couple had to make their way through a labyrinth of both geographical borders and “paper borders” – borders not on a map, but in bureaucracies, something that you can’t go though even when you’ve crossed a geographic border (Wyman, 1968). In Ruslan and Huseyin’s case, these borders pierced through one of the most intimate parts of life – love and family, separating the couple from each other (Kocher, n.d.).

    “My picture of Finland as a country of justice and equality had already been crushed then. I also got to know that my parents couldn’t come to live with me either. And especially my dad – because I’m not marked in his passport as his son (he is my officially stepdad) – and he can’t even visit Finland as my dad. <…> We couldn’t unite [with Huseyin]. Finland rejected the partner visa for Huseyin first – they said something like “there is not enough proof that you are a couple and that Huseyin has enough finances for the trip”. — Ruslan

    Then we decided to get married in Finland, but Finland didn’t allow that either, because they required my husband to have an A-type residence permit. At that time, he only had a B-type permit, so we didn’t meet their criteria again. <…> It was a huge disappointment. We were already struggling with many other problems, and this was just one more painful obstacle. <…> Heterosexual couples generally don’t face the same obstacles. They are usually able to get married in their home countries, which gives them an advantage and makes the process easier.”. — Huseyin

    “We contacted many organizations, such as Seta and Amnesty, to get support, but no authority really acknowledged or supported our relationship during that time. Seta told us that they only deal with situations happening inside Finland and that they couldn’t help us, even though our case was clearly connected to Finland. It felt like we were treated as if our relationship didn’t matter, like strangers, not as a real couple trying to build a life together.” — Huseyin

    “We got to know that Portugal and Demark allow you to marry even if you are not a citizen or a migrant with a residence permit. I wrote to one Danish service but they said that “technically we are happy to make you married, but Denmark won’t let you in if they know you’re coming here to marry”. We felt trapped and completely crushed.” — Ruslan

    Eventually, the couple found a way past the borders so that Huseyin could come to Ruslan. But it wasn’t unconditional. Their love had to be bought, printed on paper, and checked. The couple was lucky to have enough resources – but far not everyone can pass through such borders.

    “My parents found us some business that helps same-sex couples to get married. We sent them an email. They came up with a plan with getting married in Mexico, in a safe state there with a safe judge who would do that for us. We had to pay about 6,000€ for the marriage plus 2000€ for the flights. We didn’t have this money, so my parents helped.“ — Ruslan

    “It was really expensive, but we had no other option. This was the only way for us to make our marriage possible, since Finland didn’t give us the chance to marry there. <…> We felt happy because we were finally able to get married. But at the same time, it didn’t fully feel like a real celebration of love. It could have been so different, so much more meaningful, less expensive, and less emotionally exhausting. Instead, it felt like something we had to buy or complete just to be together legally, rather than something our love was naturally allowed to lead us to.” — Huseyin

    With one border crossed, the struggles didn’t vanish. More obstacles and requirements arrived with the process of family reunification. This, too, felt conditional for the couple. A state that claims to value “the family” again created barriers to forming one. The absurdity of these borders was in the income requirements. Those implied that “love is only for thiose who have money.” In addition, if before the future of their family depended on getting marriage from a faraway office, now it was at the mercy of an employer.

    “After we got married, my husband had to change his job and move to another hospital, because Migri required him to have a higher salary in order to apply for family reunification. I always think of it as if my husband had to “buy time” just to be able to be with me as a family. It’s a really strange and unfair system.” — Huseyin

    “The point is, amanuenssi salaries are really low, I had a little above 1600 €/ month, and family reunification demanded that the gross salary would be at least 1700€/month. At that time, I had no savings – everything went to the marriage in Mexico. So I had to change my work to something higher-paid. I was literally forced to do it. I only had a type B [residence permit], and they were short-term from 6 months to a year. Even family reunification felt under threat because of those B type permits. The bureaucracy in Finland is super slow, and I was always afraid that by the time they take our application in Migri my residence permit will already have just 2-3 months left. I learned to distrust Migri and thought: they wouldn’t accept family reunification for my husband for only 3 months. So I had to beg my employer to give me at least a year-long contract.” — Ruslan

    “I sent it to DVV and I remember it went to Rovaniemi, where all marriage registrations are processed. Huseyin and I were anxious – will they accept our marriage? And then the new struggle started. There was a QR code on that certificate and they couldn’t read it. I spent half a year writing a head specialist in DVV, the marriage company that we paid to, the court in Mexico, and the Mexican embassy. Eventually the Mexican embassy wrote some paper saying that our marriage certificate is true and correct and sent it to Rovaniemi. Then after some time they finally registered us as married.” — Ruslan

    “Family reunification also felt scary. They sent us a pile of forms online that we had to fill in – they asked for “proof” that we are a couple. We were supposed to attach all our tickets for visiting each other, photos, write our story, etc, etc. We were afraid: what if they won’t believe us this time? We even contacted a specialist to just be sure that we do everything right. That’s how anxious we were then. <…> I had to collect and organize all the details of our relationship, our story, photos, and other evidence, and turn it into a kind of personal document to prove that our relationship is real. We also had to provide many official papers, including bank statements and other personal documents about me. I also had to attend an interview at VFS Global in Turkey. The whole process was emotionally exhausting and made me feel like I had to ‘prove’ our love just to be together. <…> I felt like we had to prove our relationship – even after we got married. <…> It was obvious that they didn’t believe our relationship at first. They asked for so many documents and proof, which made the whole process much harder for us. It really felt like we were treated as if our relationship was fraudulent until we could prove otherwise.” — Huseyin

    Just like Ruslan and Huseyin, Tata, who moved from Russia to the US, also faced a cascade of struggles and obstacles. Alexandra Novitskaya describes those in her study (2025):

    “Tata who originally applied for asylum together with her partner, had experienced immigrant precarity on more than one level: her relationship ended in a bitter breakup, so she had to restart her asylum application by herself, which turned out to be financially costly, forcing her to continuously work overtime to afford the immigration attorney’s fees, all the while enduring depression, loneliness, and isolation. On top of all that, the USCIS asylum processing queue reversal in January 2018 pushed Tata’s application, which had been filed before the reversal date, to the back of the application backlog, adding years to her waiting for the asylum interview.“

    Borderlines asked Ruslan to imagine his experiences and paint it. He also enhanced his painting with AI. We asked this so that you, our readers, could better feel what the tricked queer migrants feel and how they see Finnish authorities.

    Ruslan and Huseyin’s story hasn’t finished. They are still in Finland, trying to solve new problems. There are many other similar stories showing how a state can lie to those who hope to build their future here. For Ruslan and Huseyin, it’s a story of betrayal:

    “It felt like betrayal. It really hurt me.”

    He tells about the “price” he feels he has to pay off:

    “I lost my work, and we are at risk of becoming undocumented. And it feels like the price for family reunification: you either live undocumented together, or I live with a residence permit, but alone, separately from my husband. We chose the first, and now we pay the price for it.“

    This “price” is what Finland can offer in return for having trusted the ideal, false picture of a “gay paradise” Finland.

    “It stole so much precious time from our life together, and that’s something I can never forget or forgive. If Finland had allowed us to marry here without obstacles, our life would have been very different. We could have built happy memories in Finland and felt that the country accepted us and valued us simply as human beings. We could have focused on our life together instead of constantly struggling with bureaucracy and proving our relationship. Unfortunately, we didn’t have that chance, and it left us feeling hurt and overlooked.”

    Just like a human trafficker, tricking people into a “good life” and then controlling them, Finland also promises “freedom” and “human rights” to queer people, but then forces them to obey harsh immigration rules, controls their work life, blocks their family life, and demands money in return for letting them live together.

    From homonationalism to queer justice

    Unfortunately, Borderlines hasn’t found any grassroots activist groups or NGOs that directly focus on the problems of family reunification for queer families. This silence (Kleinman et al., 1997) within activist circles is itself a form of harm: those who are affected by the state are not seen, heard, or even acknowledged. Because people remain silent about these issues, the state and society receive no challenging messages or demands, and the harm continues.

    Meanwhile, queer families affected by homonationalist policies do have clear views on what should be changed. For example, Ruslan wrote:

    “Migri should recognize the fact that <…> people start relationships at any stage of their life and they can’t always “cohabitate at least for 2 years” – because it’s dangerous or because immigration laws of different countries prevent that – like in our case, Turkey and Russia. <…> Same-sex couples are already discriminated by their [forced queer families’] home countries – Finland should stop discriminate them additionally. This requirement, “If neither spouse is a Finnish citizen or lives in Finland, they must … submit to the Digital and Population Data Services Agency a clarification on whether the legislation in their home country allows them to get married in Finland”, should be removed for same-sex couples.”

    Yet, such demands are often ignored. Why?

    At the state level, as we already described in the first post, homonationalism is at play. This means that only (some) Finnish and Western LGBTQ+ people are valued, while LGBTQ+ people from other parts of the world are labelled “homophobic” and “untrustworthy”. Their dignity and rights are dismissed. This is especially evident in the current climate of hostile anti-immigrant rhetoric.

    Within activist circles, homonationalism also exists, even if it does not always stem from conscious belief. It can take the form of homonationalism by outcome: activists may hold values that oppose homonationalist ideas, yet their practices still exclude LGBTQ+ migrants in Finland.

    Borderlines spoke with a queer migrant activist who expressed deep dissatisfaction with the way queer spaces in Finland exclude migrants. He stated that Seta groups do not demand LGBTQ+ justice for migrants out of fear of losing government funding. In his view, many activists believe that defending migrants’ rights is something the government would disapprove of.

    We cannot verify whether this fear is justified. However, it is true that Seta relies on government funding:

    “Seta finances its activities with support from STEA, the Ministry of Education and Culture, and municipalities <…> Seta supports the activities of its member organisations through annual grants.”

    STEA in Finland stands for the State Endowment for Health and Social Welfare (Sosiaali- ja terveysjärjestöjen avustuskeskus), a government body that grants funding to various organizations for activities promoting health and social well-being. It works under the Ministry of Social Affairs and Health and is responsible for handling grant applications, managing payments, and monitoring the use and outcomes of the funding. 

    A Seta member organization, Rainbow Families ry (Sateenkaariperheet ry), published a political program on their website, which states that

    “Rainbow families receive protection in Finland and can move freely from one state to another.”

    However, based on the published document, the program does not include any clear advocacy for equality in queer family reunification between EU and non-EU citizens, nor does it address the obstacles to same-sex marriage in Finland:

    Rainbow families face inhumane situations when moving or travelling within Europe. <…> In the context of family reunification, possible rainbow family relationships must be taken into account, as they are highly likely to have no legal status in the country of origin.”

    This inaction, stemming from dependency on the state, contradicts the NGO’s own commitments. It contributes to the homonationalist paradox of Finland as a “gay haven”:

    “Those in power, in particular, must recognise their responsibility and understand that discriminatory speech cannot be accepted under the guise of apparent tolerance: tolerating differing opinions is desirable only as long as it does not violate the dignity and rights of others.”

    According to research, this problem is not specific to Seta, LGBTQ organizations, or even Finnish NGOs. It is a common issue for many NGOs that rely on public funding (Banks et al., 2015; Parks, 2008; Kelsall et al., 2023). Through the conditions attached to funding, the state can influence which goals and topics an NGO pursues and which it avoids. Often, the state silences initiatives that conflict with the priorities of dominant groups in government. This renders social movements “tamed” and less radical.

    As a result, unjust systems and structures persist or are only minimally changed. In the case of LGBTQ+ injustice, changes occur only along the homonationalist lines defined by the Finnish government itself.

    This neglect isolates queer migrants, weakens solidarity with them, and causes harm:

    “I felt lonely in Finland. <…> talking to others felt useless – they were all talking about their families, how they spent time together, what they do – and I could only tell about separation, trauma, and loneliness. I already tried first – but I felt people don’t understand, don’t wanna talk about this or just become pity of me. And no one wanted to change anything in Finland. So I just abandoned this idea to make friends.” – Ruslan

    “Seta told us that they only deal with situations happening inside Finland and that they couldn’t help us, even though our case was clearly connected to Finland. It felt like we were treated as if our relationship didn’t matter ,like strangers, not as a real couple trying to build a life together. <…> it was as if we were not considered valuable or worthy of the same rights just because we are from outside the EU. <…> We were completely left alone to figure everything out by ourselves.” – Huseyin

    Some may argue that even though the state’s homonationalist ideology is clear, the Finnish government places LGBTQ+ NGOs in a difficult position: they must choose between advocating for Finnish queer people (and excluding queer migrants) or risking loss of funding and potentially failing to defend queer dignity more broadly.

    However, this dilemma—queer citizens versus queer migrants—is false. For example, the European Commission against Racism and Intolerance (ECRI) published a report in 2025 stating that public officials, politicians, and ordinary people in Finland increasingly use hate speech, targeting both racial/ethnic minorities and queer people. Additionally, a study by the Police University College (Unlu et al., 2025) found that hate crimes in Finland are increasingly motivated by both race/ethnicity and queer identity. Across the Global North, the rise of far-right politicians often goes hand in hand with opposition to both immigration and LGBTQ+ rights (Murib, 2025; Weeks & Allen, 2023).

    Even if an organization chooses to focus only on the rights of queer citizens, this would not ensure long-term security and dignity. Research shows that when the state and society begin to label one social group as a threat, over time, other groups are often labeled the same way (Diez, 2023; Eroukhmanoff, 2018; Farinha & Youngs, 2024). Today, immigration may be framed as a “national security concern”; tomorrow, it could be the “rainbow movement.” The label of threat spreads, gradually encompassing more and more people.

    This situation is not unsolvable.

    Until the change is achieved, NGOs should be open and transparent about their limits and reasons for this. That doesn’t deny the responsibility for providing help either through opening services for queer migrants or through collaborations with other NGOs, which do that.

    (originally published: December 1, 2025)

    How to cite this article (APA style)
    References

    The climate of hate toward queer people:

  • People become family members not because of their common genetics. They build their families by doing a lot of different things: buying gifts for each other, cooking for their children, providing comfort to those who are stressed or upset, sending money to those who need them and so on. Some people may decide to stop being a family, for example because of abuse – and they stop doing such things for each other (O’Reilly, n.d.; Walls, 2007; Söderbäck, 2010).

    Sometimes people may even forcibly prevent someone from making a family – think of a divorced mother who doesn’t let her son see his safe father and the son wants this himself. In courts this is often called parental alienation – meaning the situation when one parent undermines the relationship of their child with another parent. Parental alienation is a form of violence especially when it’s coercive and especially because it is harmful for the child and the separated parent (Thompson & Kaplan, 1996; Blotcky, 2022; Cantor, 2022).

    State’s responsibility for breaking families

    Violence isn’t only something an individual person can do. States can also force people into harmful situations where they experience pain and suffering – something that is called structural violence (Cantor, 2022).

    A state can also forcibly separate families in many ways (e.g., Madziva & Zontini, 2012; Goetze, 2022; Canning & Bhatia, 2022). On 15 December 2023 the Finnish authorities decided to indefinitely close all the crossing points on the Eastern border in Finland (Finnish border guard, 2025; Helsinki Times, 2025), which prevented families from seeing each other easily (Krivonos & Diatlova, 2023; Kainulainen, 2024). This decision forcibly separated many family members from each other, preventing them from “making” their families and thus weakening or even destroying family ties. Most of such families are Russian-speaking.

    Who have we talked to?

    Ekaterina is a mother of two adopted children and one biological child. All three have neuropsychological issues, and in the case of the eldest child, they are so severe that he requires constant supervision by two adults and currently lives in a special care institution, though he occasionally comes home. Her mother, who lives in Vyborg, regularly helped her with raising children. Ekaterina lives in Lappeenranta.

    Elena Leontieva is a physician from Lappeenranta who has been living in Finland for more than 20 years. Her daughter Maria and her son Denis are currently living in Petrozavodsk.

    Tatiana (personal details changed) moved to Finland in 2016 and lives in Pienimetsä, where she was a PhD student in engineering physics. Tatiana faced obstacles in the process of reuniting with her son due to COVID restrictions and financial requirements, and Migri did not allow her child to move to Finland. Her mother and son currently live together in Dalnegrad.

    All of them highlighted that flying by plane or gathering in other countries like Turkey is too expensive for them and they cannot do that at all or can do that only very rarely.

    It’s also important to notice that far not everyone from family members is actually allowed to visit their relatives because of the EU visa policies and residence permit policies in Finland.

    “Only those with a residence permit or citizenship in Finland can travel from Russia to Finland through Estonia. So, my daughter wouldn’t be allowed through Estonia to visit me. If she were to travel through Turkey or Norway (which would be even longer and more expensive than the route through Estonia), my grandson wouldn’t be allowed into Finland either. Finland only permits parents, children, and spouses of residents to enter.” —Elena

    “Before the border closures, my family could visit me on a visa, but now they are not allowed to enter other Schengen countries (due to sanctions from Finland). And there’s no possibility to fly via non-Schengen countries. As a result, because of the closed borders, we are seeing our family and friends much less often. They can’t visit me.” — Tatiana

    Stealing time

    Sociologists Monish Bhatia and Victoria Canning in their book Stealing Time: Migration, Temporalities and State Violence (2022) described how the authorities can “steal” time from people. For Russian-speaking family members this stolen time is the time that could have been spent in their families.

    Ekaterina describes this as “what’s missing is the time spent together, shared joys” and feels that “That time is passing, life is going on, and something important is slipping away from us.”

    The “stolen” time is something that cannot be returned, for example, because a family member may die and leave a person without any opportunity to see that family member ever again. For example, Borderlines contacted one woman who had lost her mother behind the closed border, but refused to give an interview.

    “I don’t know if I’ll see my aunt alive, as she is very weak right now.” — Elena

    After Borderlines came back to Elena 4 months later after the interview to show how Borderlines will use Elena’s experiences, she told us that the aunt has died and Elena didn’t manage to visit her before her death.

    Elena wrote about the “stolen” experiences of witnessing the important milestones in her little grandson’s life—moments that can never be “replayed” again:

    “I was fortunate to be present at my grandson’s birth. Then I saw him at six months old. But unfortunately, I’ve missed watching him grow and develop new skills. I didn’t see his first tooth, nor his first steps… “

    Preventing being a mom and a granny

    Motherhood consists of small actions like giving gifts to their children, playing with them, cooking for them, calming them down when they feel stressed and so on (Walls, 2007). Mothers who migrated away from their children still can keep being mothers by sending gifts, luxuries, and other goods to their children – a replacement for the lack of physical closeness from faraway. However, for Russian-speaking mothers this is not possible anymore:

    • On April 11, 2022, Finland’s national postal service, Posti, suspended all letter and parcel traffic between Finland and Russia, as well as between Finland and Belarus (Posti, 2022).
    • Moreover, on June 23, 2022, the Association of European State Postal Operators, PostEurop, suspended the membership rights of Russian Post and Belposhta (Belarus’ postal service) (Ukraine’s national post, 2022).
    • Finland stopped giving tourist visas to Russian nationals effective 30 September 2022, citing concerns over international relations and security following Russia’s military actions in Ukraine (Finland Abroad, 2022).
    • On 19 September 2022, Estonia, along with Latvia, Lithuania, and Poland, banned entry for all Russian citizens with short-stay Schengen visas at their borders (Republic of Estonia. Government, 2022).
    • According to official announcements, these restrictions last as long as the governments want

    When border policies prevent mothers from doing this for their children, they “break” families apart so that mothers cannot be mothers anymore or feel as if they “failed” in being mothers. The same is also true for grandmothers and grandchildren.

    Elena whose daughter Maria and her grandson Denis were separated from her by the closure of the Eastern border experiences the same “failure” in being both a mother and a grandmother:

    “But what kind of mental state can I have when I can’t send a little money to my family? My daughter isn’t working right now; she’s on maternity leave. As a result, she’s financially constrained. And I can’t help her financially because money transfers to Russia are banned.I can’t send them gifts for Christmas and birthdays! Because postal services to Russia are not accepted. I’m constantly plagued by a sense of guilt that I’m not giving my family what I could: emotional warmth, pleasant experiences, or material expressions of my love like gifts. During the rare meetings with my daughter, I feel she misses my attention, care, and advice.”

    Tatiana, Elena, and Ekaterina mentioned that online communication doesn’t really replace real connections with their families and that this lack harms their families by forcefully weakening or even breaking them.

    “I want to be able to meet friends and other relatives in Finland, so my brother can come with his family. Our children haven’t seen each other for almost 3 years and are starting to forget each other. The youngest is 5 years old, and she doesn’t even remember my brother and my cousin. We communicate through video calls, of course, but it’s just not the same. <…> They haven’t even had the chance to get to know each other. They don’t know what to talk about when we call each other. They know so little about each other.In the short conversation, where the adults also participate, they don’t manage to get to know each other. The kids can’t run around together, laugh, or play on video.” — Ekaterina

    “We see each other so infrequently now. Talking via video call is not the same as being together and sitting close, hugging” — Elena

    “I can’t have normal conversations with my loved ones. It’s not just about talking but also about having the possibility to hug, hold hands. Now, it feels like we are deprived of this contact…” — Tatiana

    Ekaterina told how the closure of border prevented her mother from caring for her children and her, which was really needed. The lack of this made her situation with difficult children even more exhausting than before.

    “My mom could come every other week. That would mean more help, I’d know I could manage for a week and then she’d be here. Now, she comes rarely, once every six months. I’m working 100% time. Besides that, I have the house, shopping, cleaning to manage. All of that is on me, as well as numerous meetings with psychologists, social workers, teachers, therapists, and doctors.When my mom comes, she naturally takes a lot on herself, like cleaning, spending time with the youngest, picking her up from daycare. She helps the middle one with her homework. And she helps me with cooking. It’s just more fun with her here—she plays with the kids, reads to them, and we even bake muffins together. Without my mom, it’s very hard.”

    Harms continue

    Such “theft” of time and weakening of families harm Russian-speaking families.

    Elena, a physician, who feels that she cannot be fully a mother and a grandmother to her daughter and son feels “terrible about the situation” and “acute sense of loneliness”:

    “I’m depressed about everything that’s happening. It’s genuine clinical depression. <…> This situation with the prolonged border closure has drained me emotionally, the feeling of lightness has disappeared, and a strong anxiety and heaviness in my heart have appeared. <…> My interest in life has significantly decreased; I’ve abandoned all my hobbies as they no longer bring me joy. I just go to work and home. I don’t go anywhere else, and I don’t want to. I feel like some sort of robot.”

    Tatiana shares:

    When the borders were closed, we hoped it would be temporary. I actively participated in events organized by Russian-speaking people in Finland. But then came apathy. I struggled to get out of bed, couldn’t sleep without medication. My condition worsened, and the depression score increased. It became difficult to leave the house because I had no idea if I would be able to visit my family for the holidays.”

    Just like an abusive parent who doesn’t let her child see his second parent, the Finnish government also becomes violent and  forcefully keeps family members apart from each other by indefinitely shutting down the possibilities for connections.  Such families miss irreplaceable, valuable life moments and care that cannot be ever replayed again and in some way fail to keep being families, which creates pain.

    Protecting Finnish democracy or undermining it?

    On 15 December 2023 the Finnish authorities decided to indefinitely close all the crossing points on the Eastern border in Finland. The border is closed temporarily until further notice, which means that the government can keep it closed as long as they want. The authorities have done this due to their fear that Russia would somehow bring chaos to Finnish society by deliberately pushing humanitarian migrants into Finland.

    Press releases also say that the closure is

    Authorities believe that the closure stopped instrumentalised migration entirely:

    Besides closing the border, the Finnish government  passed a “pushback” law, which allows Finnish border guards to stop and turn back those people who are crossing the border.

    Experts and human rights groups disagreed:

    • It breaks international law by denying people the right to seek asylum
    • It weakens democracy
    • It normalizes pushbacks, which are illegal, making exclusion and breaking the international laws seem “normal”
    • It dehumanizes migrants, calling them threats instead of people

    (Aaltonen & Sajari, 2024; Könönen, 2025; UNHCR, 2024; Amnesty International, 2024)

    Separation of Russian-speaking families is possibly an unintended side-effect of such border policies.

    “I’m confident the decision to close the borders is political, disguised as concern for citizens. I believe the danger from migrants can be minimized in other ways.” — Ekaterina

    The issue of separated Russian-speaking families has not been completely silent.

    In 2023, Kimmo Kiljunen became a Foreign Affairs Committee Chair. The Foreign Affairs Committee in Finland’s Parliament looks at how the country deals with other countries, including foreign policy, international agreements, and global issues like development and peace.

    In October 2024 Kiljunen met with Aleksanterinliitto, a Finnish NGO that works to support and protect the rights, freedoms, culture, and legal status of Russian-speaking Finns and related communities in Finland. On the meeting, Kiljunen called for reopening the Eastern border and accused the closure as violating human rights. He argued that the closed border violated family rights of the Russian-speaking families with family members living on both sides from the closed border. He also told that the closure of the border prevents Russian opposition from fleeing the country. He criticized Finnish tabloid media for exaggerating the threat coming from migrants crossing the eastern border. The video from this meeting got into and spread in the social media, reaching the authorities and journalists. In November 2024, the Prime Minister Petteri Orpo called Kiljunen’s statements “a big problem”, while President Alexander Stubb said those in foreign policy roles must speak with “one voice”.  Even though Kiljunen has never had any pro-Kremlin positions and supported imprisoned Russian opposition activists, leaders of Kiljunen’s own party (SDP) distanced themselves from him saying that he was speaking only for himself. Such pressure led Kiljunen to make a public apology and resign from his duties as Chair of the Foreign Affairs Committee in late 2024 (Bjurström & Orjala, 2024; Joukanen et al., 2024; Novaya Gazeta Europe, 2024; YLE News, 2024).

    Ivan Deviatkin is a Russian-speaking politician and a city council in Lappeenranta who has been criticizing the closure of the Eastern border. Ivan experienced an attack on his personality from newspapers labeling him “pro-Putin”:

    On 29 May 2025, the Lappeenranta Left Alliance council group dismissed Deviatkin from the Left Alliance council group, making him an unaffiliated member, but refused to explain the reasons clearly.

    “The grounds for dismissal are Ivan Deviatkin’s inappropriate behavior at a council group meeting and repeated actions that are contrary to the party’s values. We will not comment further on the matter.” -Sara Backman, Chairman of the Lappeenranta Left Alliance council group, 30 May 2025

    Confused with both the Left Alliance’s decision and the attack by Finnish media, Deviatkin wrote a short essay on his Facebook account. In it, he told how such aggressive campaigns can create a suspicious and frightening image of politicians. This makes people distrust and afraid of what such politicians say.

    “What is the goal of such campaigns?

    First — psychological and moral pressure. Sometimes this is stated openly in articles. For example: “I don’t want to speculate, but under pressure, Deviatkin’s first decision as a city council member might be to resign from his post.” (Etelä-Saimaa, 2.6.2025). In other words, the aim is to directly pressure someone into giving up a legally obtained mandate.

    Second — marginalisation. Creating an image of “toxic” individuals whom no one would want to work with. “Collaboration with other parties stalled because of Deviatkin, even though his party was one of the winners of the election.” (Etelä-Saimaa, 4.6.2025).

    Third — attacking one’s reputation. What do colleagues and potential employers see when they Google our names? “Pro-Russian councillors stir confusion in Lappeenranta” (Etelä-Saimaa, 17.5.2025), “On a pro-Russian agenda to the council” (Ilta-Sanomat, 8.6.2025).

    <…>

    Fifth — to “warn others”. To intimidate those who, in the future, might dare to voice unpopular opinions or defend minority rights. The message is clear: “See what will happen to you — better stay silent.”

    How the media and politicians make the ideas of opposing the closure of the Eastern border seem frightening and suspicious – together with people who bring them – is an example of securitization.

    Securitization is talking about something like it’s a big threat – so dangerous that it needs urgent, special actions, even if those break normal rules in society (Eroukhmanoff, 2018).

    Features of securitization:

    • Someone with power in society (a government, a politician, or media outlet says “this is a threat” about some issue (immigration, disease, protests) and that it is dangerous to the country, its people, or its values.
    • They say that someone or something needs protection (nation, society, borders, or values). They say “We must protect ourselves from this!”
    • The public agrees. If enough people believe that his threat is real, they will let the government take extreme steps (closing borders, banning visas, lock people at homes)
    • When the public agrees, the government may skip discussing some “emergent” laws with its society. Such laws may ignore human rights or even do things that are normally illegal (like restricting freedom of movement of citizens or surveilling people)
    • It may be about one group of people in the beginning- but it may creep into people with time

    Securitization theory explains that things that are seen as a “threat” may not be so much “dangerous” in reality. Instead, people with power make certain people look like big, unusual “threats” in the ways they talk about them. It’s especially visible when we compare one “threatening” event with something similar or even bigger to which there was no such reaction from powerful people (Könönen, 2025; Aleksanterinliitto, 2025).

    At the same time, securitization of humanitarian migrants isn’t something new. Governments in other European countries already talked like the Finnish government but much earlier, before the Russian military invasion in Ukraine.

    In 2015, Spain made a law that let border guards quickly send people back if they tried to cross into the country at its North African borders near Ceuta and Melilla (Andersson, 2015; Ciemecka & Laine, 2026; Amnesty International, 2022). The government said the law was needed to stop Morocco from letting people through its territory into Spain. This made legal a practice that was already happening and had been in the news in 2005 when some people were killed at the border fence.

    During the media’s attack on Deviatkin, Anastasiia Diudina, an anti-war activist in Finland, also wrote several essays on Facebook where she blamed Deviatkin and similar politicians for being “pro-Putin” because of their call to open the border. Her statements do not have a scientific basis and are ideological instead.

    Diudina writes that “many Russians feel they have an almost innate right to reside in Finland.” But research by border studies professor Olga Davydova-Minguet and social science researcher Pirjo Pöllänen (2021) shows the opposite. Many Russian-speaking people in Finland actually face stress, fear, and uncertainty — especially when they try to visit or help family members across the border. These cross-border ties are about everyday life, not politics or threats. This is something that Borderlines also showed in our previous post.

    Diudina also writes that even anti-war Russians can be “tools for FSB influence.” The Russian FSB is the country’s main security service that watches for threats inside Russia, like spying or terrorism, and took over from the old Soviet KGB. But a study by Tatiana Oivo and Davydova-Minguet (2021) shows that these kinds of broad suspicions are not backed by real evidence. Instead, people with Russian roots — especially those with dual citizenship — are often treated as a risk just because of who they are, not because they’ve done anything wrong. This kind of thinking has been used to block people from public jobs unfairly.

    Just because someone opposes keeping the border with Russia permanently closed doesn’t mean they support the Russian government. They might actually be worried about how Finland itself is changing — for example, becoming less open to democratic debate.

    When political discussions are always treated as security threats, it becomes harder to speak up without being labeled suspicious. This is what professor of international relations Didier Bigo (2002) and professor of international politics Jef Huysmans (2006; 2011) describe in their studies.

    Securitization makes public debate look dangerous. It turns people who call for dialogue into suspected traitors. That’s why, as Bigo explains, this kind of thinking creates a “culture of unease,” where governments and officials use fear to justify silencing others. Huysmans shows how this leads to long-term harm: public institutions start seeing all migration — or any connection to “outsiders” — as a threat, even in democracies.

    When Finnish politicians are called “Russia-friendly” just for saying the border should reopen, or for wanting to keep dialogue possible — we need to ask: is this really about security, or is it about shutting down political debate?

    If we’re not careful, Finland could start copying the same tactics that made Russia an authoritarian state — where fear is used to silence opposition.

    More details about this:

    Treating issues like opposing the shut down of the Easter border as a security threat can actually harm democracy instead of protecting it.

    Political science professor Nancy Bermeo (2016) in her research explained that democracies can weaken over time when laws that are meant to protect are used to limit freedom. These could be emergency powers, giving more control to the government, or silencing critics. This gradual loss of freedoms is known as executive aggrandizement (where leaders gain more power (Laebens, 2023)).

    According to the Varieties of Democracy (V-Dem) Institute, led by Professor M. Laebens (2023), global data shows that democratic standards have been getting worse since 2006. Security arguments have been used to justify cutting back people’s rights, controlling the media, and weakening the courts. The Marshall Center (Gashaj et al., 2023) adds that security organizations are often used to push loyalty to the government, which can move a democracy closer to becoming an authoritarian state (where one person or group has too much power).

    The Carnegie Endowment (Farinha & Youngs, 2024) also warns that European policies focusing too much on security in areas like migration and Russia may unintentionally harm democracy by ignoring other important values.

    This isn’t just a suggestion. The Democratic Erosion project, which includes researchers from Harvard and other universities, has already pointed out that debates about migration and security in Finland could threaten the country’s democracy — especially when those who disagree are labeled as “disloyal.” (Koc University, 2020; 2022)

    (see the references below in the section “Securitization in Russia” and “Securitization in Finland”)

    “I grew up hearing from the government that all of this was for “our own safety.” In the end, it led to Russians not even having the right to express their opinions freely. I worry a lot that Finland could change—from a free country into something with fewer human rights, with more restrictions. And it could happen so gradually that no one even notices. Like they say, if you want to boil a frog, you have to do it slowly. It won’t even realize it’s being cooked. Politics works the same way. A little here, a little there. And then suddenly, there’s no way out…” Tatiana

    Excluding one group conveys the meaning that excluding a group is possible in principle—and history shows it rarely stops with only one group. This “slippery slope” is well-documented: treating migration and people living on the border as a security threat often leads to a broader democratic decline. Exclusion becomes normalized first at the “border,” then creeps inward to welfare, speech, and participation. Recognizing early warning signs—like Finland’s current securitized asylum and border policies—can help prevent weakening democracy in Finland.

    From 1949 to 1989, the Federal Republic of Germany (West Germany) was a democratic state bordering the German Democratic Republic (East Germany)—an authoritarian regime aligned with the USSR. By 1961, around 3.45 million East Germans crossed into West Germany, usually legally or semi-legally, without being framed as “security threats.” Many migrated for economical and political reasons. Even after building the Berlin Wall in 1961, West German policy remained laws-based and rights-oriented, not emergency-driven. Border crossings were family visits or business, managed under regulatory frameworks rather than security emergencies (Becker et al., 2020; Fröhlich, 2023; Gehrig, 2023; Jarausch, 1994).

     How West Germany avoided securitization:

    1. No framing migrants from East Germany as existential threats to West Germany: political leaders in West Germany portrayed migration as a liberating movement—not a threat.
    2. Legal protections remained intact: East Germans crossing borders received social and legal support, not suspicion or exclusion.
    3. People emphasized humanitarian, familial, and political reasons of why people migrate from East Germany—not the threats to “capitalist values”, society or security.

    Democracy and security can coexist without securitization. Even amid ideological rivalry and military tension, West Germany upheld legal and humanitarian approaches. West Germany emphasized rights, not fear. Border communities were treated with human dignity, not suspicion, even near the “Iron Curtain.” The Eastern border today could look like this—balancing vigilance with law, inclusivity, and procedural fairness, even in challenging contexts.

    (originally published: June 18, 2025)

    How to cite this article (APA style)
    References

    Securitization in Finland:

    Securitization in Russia:

  • If someone kills another person without a justified reason, we often say that this is a murder that should be followed with legal consequences: an investigation, a case in a court, and some punishment or compensation that should be forced upon a person who committed a murder. The person who helped commit a murder would most likely be condemned as an accomplice in crime who will also have consequences for their actions.

    A person or even many people can also be killed by a group of people organized in a certain way, like a social institution, a company, or even a government of a state.  For asylum seekers, such violence can be done both in the countries that they fled, and in the countries that they fled to.

    One way such violence can happen in the countries that they arrived at is with the use of a state’s bureaucracy, which is called bureaucratic violence (Eldridge & Reinke, 2018).

    Nadim, who fled from Afghanistan to Finland and got a negative asylum decision after the asylum practices became tightened in 2016, described the situation that he and many others faced by 2017 like this:

    “In Afghanistan the Taliban kills with guns; in Finland the government kills with pens”.

    He wanted to say that the way in which Finnish authorities processed his claim for asylum and his possible deportation to Afghanistan meant that he would certainly be murdered – something done both by the Taliban and Finnish authorities together. The Finnish bureaucracy would also participate in killing Nadim. It would allow Nadim’s murder by the Taliban by rejecting his claim for safety and deporting him back to Afghanistan under the Taliban (Näre, 2020).

    Bureacuracy as a machine of violence

    Bureaucracies can be found in the public sector (Ritzer & Stepninsky, 2018):

    • They consist of offices and work in them is organized by rules
    • Each office has its own function, and there are ways to compel office workers to follow the rules (for example, by removing a worker from the office if they don’t follow the rules properly)
    • These offices are organized in a hierarchy with higher offices guiding the work of lower ones
    • The roles that people take working in an office may require some qualifications (for example, you need to have a degree in law to work as a law expect who assesses asylum claims)
    • All decisions, rules, and actions that workers do are recorded in papers or electronically

    Such complicity to murder is done by many people working in many organizations in Finland.

    • The Immigration Office (Migri) officers process asylum applications.
    • The way Migri officers work is directed by the officials working in the Ministry of the Interior.
    • The officials working in the Ministry of the Interior use the guidelines made by the officials in the Finnish government.
    • The officials in the Administrative Court and the Supreme Administrative Court process the appeals of the asylum decisions made by Migri officials.
    • Police officers and border guards get the decisions from Migri officials and then according to them force those asylum seekers who get a negative decision out of Finland to the countries where they can be murdered.
    “A death sentence in disguise”

    Borderlines interviewed 3 people who escaped from Russia to Finland, applied for asylum but received a negative decision.

    Alexey Karachevsky and Andrey are a same-sex couple who lived in Russia together. They registered their marriage in 2019 in Portugal. Even though they lived in the same apartment, they didn’t live openly as a same-sex couple. Yet, in April 2022, after they expressed their disapproval of Russian invasion in Ukraine, their neighbors tried to attack them and started to threaten them with phone calls and spreading leaflets in the house referring to them as pedophiles. Because of that they had to urgently flee from Russia. On January 3 2025 they received a negative decision from Migri. They appealed it at the Administrative Court and are now waiting for its decision.

    Maria Moskvina and her wife lived in Russia until their sexual orientation became known and they started to get threats. The threats also came to them because of their oppositional views regarding Putin’s regime. After they fled Russia, police officers even arrived at the place where Maria was registered to figure out her current location. In Finland they received a negative decision from Migri and then later also the Administrative Court supported Migri’s decision. They tried to appeal this in the Supreme Administrative Court, but their appeal wasn’t taken for consideration. Now Maria and her wife applied for asylum in Finland for the second – and last possible – time.

    Just like Nadim, Alexey, Andrey, and Mariia also feel like bureaucracy can actually kill or harm–not only him personally but also his friends and his husband:

    “To us, this [the negative decision] sounds like …. a death sentence in disguise. <…>At stake are the fates and lives of real people who are facing persecution in Russia. <…> Our lives, the lives of our friends, the asylum seekers. People whom Migri wants to send back to their home country. <…> And after the war started, I realized that gay people would be labeled as the “fifth column,” a group to be persecuted and destroyed in the name of “traditional values.” I know history well enough to recognize the parallels with Nazi Germany in the 1930s. I have no desire to end up in prison with a metaphorical pink triangle.” – Andrey

    “I don’t think [coming back to Russia] is possible. Almost every LGBTQ person struggles to come to terms with their identity, no matter their age. Most of the time, you can’t turn to family or close ones for support because you either know—or fear—that they’ll judge you or even cut you off entirely. Russian society, in general, is deeply homophobic. I’m sure everyone has heard jokes or negative comments about the LGBTQ community. … And what’s worse, you know that no one will protect you—except maybe yourself or your partner.” – Maria

    Migri and the whole bureaucratic system involved in asylum policies becomes complicit with violence toward LGBTQ+ people done by the Russian state and society. By failing to provide safety for Russian LGBTQ+ people, this system becomes responsible for the violence consequences following the negative asylum decisions.

    The situation around LGBTQ+ people in Russia

    The negative attitudes of Russian citizens toward LGBTQ+ people have been increasing during 2010-20’s.

    According to the beliefs of Russian citizens, meeting LGBTQ+ people or seeing them on TV, reading about them in books is like being exposed to the blood of a person infected with a dangerous blood-transmitted disease or the cough of a COVID-positive person. Many Russians think that queer identities such as homosexuality and transsexuality belong in the same category as “pedophilia”. They believe these can “transmit” from person to person or when a person, especially a child, sees, for example, an LGBTQ+ flag or a couple of men holding hands. Such views are shaped by the Russian authorities and have roots in Europe when Peter the Great in 1716 and later Nicholas I decided to “civilize” Russian society and imported homophobia from Europe of that time (Healey, 2005; Duberman et al., 1989).

    Sociologist Alexandra Novitskaya writes in her study (2023) that anti-queer laws in the post-Soviet countries appeared after the Soviet Union fell apart. The post-Soviet governments or general public were anxious of the influence from the West (for example, promoting democratic ideas) or of a transition happening in many states when less people are born and the part of society that consists of elderly people grows.

    Russian authorities have tried to actively restrict and criminalize LGBTQ+ people’s presence in public already since 2013 when they introduced the new law prohibiting “LGBT propaganda” among minors, which in fact criminalized any attempts of LGBTQ+ people to publicly demand their rights.

    In 2022, together with invading Ukraine, the Russian government banned mentioning LGBTQ themes in positive or neutral tone publicly, and only a negative and condemning narrative became permitted by law. In fact, this excluded LGBTQ+ people in Russia from participation in society (Human Rights Watch, 2022; Kosilkin & Kochekovsky, 2024).

    In the summer 2023 Russian authorities banned transgender people from transition and thus prohibited hormonal treatment or psychological support (Amnesty International, 2023).

    In fall of 2023 the Supreme Court in Russia called the “international LGBT movement” extremist. This happened because authorities saw ideals of LGBTQ+ rights as opposing “Russian traditional values”. The Supreme Court explained that the “movement” has an “inherently destructive ideological mechanism of influence” that leads to self-destruction of society, weakens family ties, harms moral health, and imposes ideas that imply the denial of human dignity and the value of human life” (OVD-Info, 2025; Kosilkin & Kochekovsky, 2024).

    This change is exactly what Alexey mentioned too:

    “in Russia, we’ve been equated to extremists, and for openly participating in the LGBTQ community, we will all face criminal charges.”

    Human rights organizations, such as Human Rights Watch (2024) echo Alexey:

    OVD-Info (2025) mentions that the decision doesn’t explain what exactly should be perceived as the “international LGBT movement”. That’s why police officers in Russia decide on their own who to arrest and what for. There is no agreement on what logic police officers in Russia use. The threat of violence is unpredictable. Moreover, police started to make informal lists of LGBTQ+ people in Russia, and a recent investigation by Meduza (2025) agency showed that keeping registers of LGBTQ+ people in Russia became a governmental guideline, the purpose of which is not yet known.

    The claim of extremism was used for Andrey Kotov, a tourism agency owner, in 2023 (Human Rights Watch, 2025). Even though he wasn’t actually an LGBTQ+ activist, simply being an LGBTQ+ person became the reason to apply the law, arrest him and send to prison. Because LGBTQ+ people are perceived as morally inferior to others, the humiliating treatment of Kotov in the prison ended with his death.

    Sociologist Alexandra Novitskaya in her study (2023) showed that such anti-queer laws and media make LGBTQ+ people in Russia visible for others – not like in Western democracies where LGBTQ+ people become visible as people fighting for their rights and equality, but instead as people who are dangerous and morally failed who should be always on watch. Even those who would like to be seen as usual people with a spouse or partner of the same gender or who transitioned at some point in their life – are forced into being always the center of heightened attention, suspicion, and threats from others.

    This makes LGBTQ+ people be constantly exposed to the risk of violence from others. The anti-queer laws kind of tell queerphobic people that the state is on their side:

    “You never know where the threat might come from—relatives who champion “traditional values,” police enforcing barbaric laws, or neighbors who have been trained by the authorities to fear and hate anything different—whether it’s someone’s thoughts, appearance, or way of life.” – Andrey

    Unpredictability was an important feature of Andrey and Alexey’s story, when their neighbors heard them criticizing the Russian government for invading Ukraine and paid their attention to the fact that Andrey and Alexey were living in the same apartment. This led neighbors to threaten Andrey and Alexey and so the couple fled from the country.

    Being in the focus of such public and state’s attention creates a feeling that queerphobia is everywhere and the threat “lingers over” you all the time. One of people who Alexandra Novitskatya interviewed, Anya, a lesbian woman from Russia, told that “her life before immigrating was filled entirely with “homophobia, transphobia, and all the other phobias.”” This describes well how queerphobia is everywhere and all the time around LGBTQ+ people in Russia.  Novitsakaya adds that “obviously, the “region-wide climate of hate” that befell the queer communities in the former Soviet Union in the 2010s, largely limited post-Soviet LGBTQ people’s ability to have a “livable life”. (Novitskaya, 2023).

    Unsplash/ Arctic Qu

    Importantly, even being in the closet doesn’t mean an LGBTQ+ person won’t face threats in the future as Alexey and Andrey’s story shows. Because such violence is unpredictable and directed against LGBTQ people as a social group, any LGBTQ+ person is at risk.

    Even those who are supposed to protect from violence due to their profession – such as police officers – can do violent actions towards LGBTQ+ people in Russia.

    In 2016, Alexandr Sidorov (Rossiyskaya LGBT-set’, 2017) organized a single-person demonstration with the slogan “Hating gays is an antiscientific delusion” in Makhachkala. After a while some young guys in masks approached him and started beating him. Some police officers who were passing by noticed that and approached the young guys. Instead of arresting them they just started talking to them. The activist had been taken to the police office where his police statement was rejected and police officers threatened to start a case against him. Some of them said that they would have acted just like the violence perpetrators and that such people like Alexandr should be burned.

    In the same year, Misha and Oleg (Samarskoye obshchestvennoye LGBT-dvizheniye “Avers”, 2018)  in Samara were stopped by police officers for drinking alcohol on the street at night. After having taken the guys to the police office, police officers inspected their backpacks and found condoms. They demanded to unblock their phones and started inspecting the content. They noticed some sexual content showing that Misha and Oleg had a relationship. Police officers insulted the guys as “pedophiles”. The police officers started to beat the guys with a stun gun, tried to record a video where Oleg would confess that he is a “pedophile”, and threatened to publish it on the internet and disclose their identities. One of the police officers openly said that he would kill Oleg, and would pour boiling water on him from a kettle. Two sergeants were called and after they arrived, one of them started to tell how joyfully he would be beating Oleg. while another tried to imagine how it was better to break Oleg’s chest. The total time of arrest lasted for about 11 hours where no food was offered. One of the sergeants let Oleg home but said that he should expect a criminal investigation. No information about Misha is known in detail. 

    To flee from violence or the threat of it, LGBTQ+ people apply for asylum abroad. However, in Finland, the threat of violence from the state doesn’t disappear.

    Why is Finnish bureaucracy violent?

    One reason why bureaucratic violence happens is because Finland’s bureaucracies such as Migri simplify the situation around LGBTQ+ people in Russia. Instead of considering the situation around LGBTQ people in Russia as changing, Migri decision makers see it as something static.

    During the last 3 years, several laws involving LGBTQ people in Russia have changed, but Migri doesn’t consider such laws in their decisions and assess safety for LGBTQ people as if the new laws don’t exist and as if LGBTQ people in Russia aren’t considered extremists.

    “As LGBT+ activists, we can be imprisoned for up to 12 years in Russia. The Finnish Migration Service decides on asylum requests based on their data about the applicants’ countries of origin. However, their information about Russia is outdated and inadequate. They do not consider the anti-LGBT laws, human rights violations, and the high level of violence against LGBT+ individuals in Russia as serious risks.” – Petition by Anna Iliukovich-Strakovskaia and Victoria Tsvetkova

    The [extremism] law wasn’t in Migri’s decision because it was passed later. The court mentioned it, but it was more like “Yes, there’s such a law,” and that was it.” – Mariia

    Both before accepting LGBTQ+ movement as extremism and after this, as we showed here, there was evidence that even police officers didn’t really protect LGBTQ+ people from violence and sometimes even committed violent actions themselves. This created a lot of fear and distrust in Russian LGBTQ+ people. In 2023, it was the state authorities that criminalized LGBTQ+ people. Yet, Migri ignores this too, providing advices and explanations that Mariia, who got a negative decision from Migri, called “absurd”:

    “Migri has no real understanding of the situation for LGBTQ people in Russia and relies on outdated information. Almost every argument they used was absurd!”

    “Based on the information about your home country, the status of being LGBTQ+ may complicate receiving official assistance, but belonging to a sexual minority in itself does not mean that a person cannot receive official protection. The migration service believes that you will still be able to expect assistance from the authorities of your country.” – Alexey

    The second reason comes from anthropologist Mariam Ticktin’s work. In her book Casualties of Care (2011), Ticktin described how in welfare states the idea to help those in need becomes “chauvinist”. Instead of assessing the circumstances where people need help and helping them based on that, bureaucracies make up ever stricter criteria about if one’s experiences “fit” the label and separate those who “deserve” help from those who “doesn’t”.

    Bureaucracy officials use some “ideal” pictures of what it means to be an asylum seeker when they create criteria for asylum. Often, such an ideal picture contains “signs” of extreme suffering. Such a picture also misses out the contexts and situations from which people try to escape (for example, laws due to which one can be arrested and thrown into a prison, public attitudes that encourage violence against some particular group of people), because this is not what a bureaucracy would evaluate in the first place. According to such an ideal picture of an asylum seeker, a person fleeing from danger should have physical or mental traumas, be raped, be sold, some of their relatives should be murdered – in this case such agencies as Migri decide that such a person “deserves” security.

    If an asylum seeker’s life experiences don’t really fit in such an ideal image, then Migri will most likely decide that such an asylum seeker doesn’t “deserve” asylum – even if that would mean a deportation to the country where such a person can be later murdered or injured.

    If someone doesn’t meet the criteria, Migri simply sends people seeking for safety back to the dangerous places. This is how Migri and other bureaucratic structures become assistants in violence done by other states to those who flee from danger.

    Andrey, who together with his husband Alexey received a negative decision from Migri, wrote that “Queerness—whether bisexuality or homosexuality—is as fundamental to a person as heterosexuality. Not being yourself, not being gay, is like ceasing to be human. That’s not life; it’s mere existence. And trying to hide it means living under constant fear of being exposed.” Andrey meant that when a state imposes criminalizing and oppressing laws on LGBTQ+ people, it’s impossible to live with dignity and safety.

    Yet, Migri doesn’t recognize people who are forced to hide themselves and living in fear as someone “deserving” security from Finland:

    Having lived in such conditions for many years is another thing that doesn’t fit the ideal picture of an asylum seeker. In Migri’s view, a person who faced some danger and escaped from the country quickly “deserves” asylum, while those who have been living in conditions not letting them be fully human for years do not:

    “The authorities acknowledged the facts of persecution and threats but deemed them insufficiently systematic to grant asylum. We had hoped that the current situation in Russia—with the complete lack of rights for LGBTQIA+ people and the threat of criminal prosecution—would be taken into account, but that didn’t happen. … the Finnish authorities deemed the threats insufficiently serious, essentially saying, “You’ve survived in these conditions for so many years—you’ll manage a little longer.” Moreover, the Finnish Immigration Service claims that we could seek protection from Russian authorities in the future.” – Alexey

    “For example: “Yes, we acknowledge that you have suffered, but it was not enough or not systematic.” And that raises the question—what is enough? Are we supposed to constantly put ourselves and our partner in danger just to prove it?Or another one: “You have demonstrated your ability to live and be in a relationship in Russia.” And that was it—no explanation, just a statement. We kept asking ourselves: What does that even mean? What are they trying to say? Yes, we lived there. Yes, it was hard. We coped however we could, sometimes we broke down. Of course, all of it affected our quality of life, our relationships, and left lasting damage on our mental health.” – Mariia

    Researchers Jaana Palander and Saara Pellander in their study (2021) pointed at yet another reason why bureaucratic violence happens.

    In 2000’s and especially after the 7/2011 incident in the US, the governments of many countries, including Finland, started to gradually perceive migrants as a threat to national security. The ideas that migrants can make society less safe pushed authorities to make immigration laws strict and moving to a country difficult. In Finland, this meant that the government became more interested in protecting the society from imagined danger and less interested in human rights of those who come to Finland. Neither Finland, nor many other states in 2000-10’s really explained how strict immigration rules would decrease risks of danger or what kind of exact threat they are afraid of.

    The government officials started to change the Finnish Aliens Act (containing immigration laws) and the way bureaucracy works assessing asylum claims and deporting. The officials kept explaining these measures as something necessary due to “national security”. This way, Migri and other immigration agencies in many other countries started to work not to protect people fleeing from danger but instead to let only some people in and exclude many others who are all labeled “potentially dangerous”.

    Bureaucracies in Finland involved in immigration are neither neutral nor objective. They create bureaucratic violence because of ideas of national security and deservingness that shape the way they work. These ideas make Migri and other bureaucracies complicit in violence done to LGBTQ+ asylum seekers by the Russian state.

    Migriäs psychological harms

    Asylum decisions and the ways bureaucracies make them are harmful not only because of what may result from them in the future, but also because they influence how LGBTQ+ asylum seekers from Russia feel and live in Finland.

    “We were upset by the rejection, but once we fully translated the decision and read Migri’s reasoning, we were devastated. <…> After Migri’s rejection, we held ourselves together as best we could. Of course, we were anxious about the future—what if the court rejected our appeal as well? What would we do then? <…> When we first arrived, I had constant nightmares about ending up back in my home country. A year later, I developed insomnia, though it went away after three to four months. <…> But things got much worse when the court of first instance rejected our appeal. We were horrified—why had we been denied again? Why were we seeing the same arguments as in Migri’s decision? Some parts of the court’s response didn’t make sense at all. <…> For about a month, we managed to stay relatively okay, but by September, our condition started deteriorating significantly. <…> Right now, my wife is struggling with severe anxiety, which also manifests physically. She has started experiencing suicidal thoughts and spends most of her time reading books. As she put it, “I’m trying to escape reality—otherwise, it becomes unbearable.” – Mariia

    From justice to ignorance and back?

    Alexey, Andrey, Mariia, and her wife all trusted Migri’s bureaucracy in the hope that it would let them live safely. Moreover, officials told them that they should trust them. In the beginning they believed them.

    “In our reception center, we were denied a lawyer, with the reasoning that we should trust the bureaucracy. ” – Alexey

    But this changed as Alexey, Andrey, Mariia and her wife started to face the ways asylum-related bureaucracy really works.

    “The negative decision undoubtedly shook our faith in justice” – Alexey

    At Borderlines we talked to Alexey, Andrey, and Mariia and they expressed their wish to keep their real names in our publication. We then consulted an asylum law specialist about possible negative influence on their Migri decisions as their court applications were in the middle of processing. We also warned them that publishing their stories and experiences with their real names can actually increase the risk of Russian authorities starting a case against some of them (Passoja, 2025) or Migri considering their activism as a way to “earn” asylum after they arrived in Finland and received their application rejected. Both of the changes in Finland and Russia are new.

    Yet, knowing all the risks and experiencing injustice, Alexey, Andrey, and Mariia repeatedly told us that they want to be heard because they want to fight injustice – even at the risk of their own safety.

    Since it was what they wanted to do, Borderlines decided to share their stories publicly – also amazed at their enormous bravery and the deep demand for justice.

    United by the unbearableness of the situation, Alexey, Andrey, Mariia, and other LGBTQ+ asylum seekers from Russia find each other, offer support, and speak out to demand change.

    “[W]e’re trying to fight for every one of us. <…> [W]e also support each other, which is very important because it’s impossible to cope with this situation alone. [W]e <…> continue to fight for our rights, including the right to be heard. <…> [D]on’t blindly trust the bureaucracy, demand a lawyer before the interview, don’t remain silent, and don’t accept injustice. Be mentally prepared for a long struggle for your right to life and safety”– Alexey

    People who are threatened by their countries of citizenship are often forced to move to other countries, which contrary to the hopes, don’t always give them safety. In this situation, asylum seekers make demands that safety is something that should be given to you regardless of what state you are in – which is itself a cosmopolitan idea. In other words, it is an idea that safety should be given to you by the world simply because you are a human being. Such cosmopolitan ideas aren’t some abstract thoughts but something states decided to accept when they ratified the Refugee Convention (the 1951 Convention Relating to the Status of Refugees) (Näre, 2020).

    “According to UNHCR, the core principle of the 1951 Geneva Convention is non-refoulement, which asserts that a refugee should not be returned to a country where they face serious threats to their life or freedom. <…> We demand that the Finnish Migration Service update their information about Russia and recognize it as a dangerous country for LGBT+ individuals….

    Petition: We respectfully urge you to update and maintain current data on the plight of LGBT+ individuals in Russia to ensure informed decisions.” – Petition by Anna Iliukovich-Strakovskaia and Victoria Tsvetkova

    Alexey also demands that Migri must reconsider the situation in Russia:

    “Authorities should update information about the country of origin and make decisions based on actual circumstances and legal practices.”

    Just because asylum seekers – regardless of a positive or negative decision – are not citizens of Finland, that doesn’t mean they cannot demand changes from the Finnish state, and the cosmopolitanism of human rights also opposes this – as if saying to Finnish authorities“you have to give me safety and let me into Finnish society because I am human”.

    Lena Näre in her research (2020) writes that asylum seekers demand safety provided by the European Convention of Human Rights by making their struggles and suffering visible for others. This is why Alexey, Andrey, and Mariia want to be heard – even though that may mean that they would be less safe after doing this.

    Citation from a decision sent from Migri: “Immigration office did not consider that you would be at risk in Russia.”

    “Our friends helped us connect with local LGBTQIA+ organizations SETA and TEMA. Currently, these organizations are preparing a joint letter of support for us and are actively raising awareness about the situation of Russian LGBTQIA+ asylum seekers with Finnish authorities and the media. … Along with other dedicated activists, we founded the project Queer Asylum: Fi, aimed at supporting LGBTQIA+ asylum seekers in Finland.  We organize protest rallies, send letters to parliamentarians and ministers. Last summer, we participated in Helsinki Pride, where through our vibrant performance, we tried to highlight the issues and threats that LGBTQIA+ people face daily in Russia to the residents of Finland and the country’s authorities.” – Alexey

    Based on our analysis, Borderlines demands that:

    1. Migri has to update its “geographical information” about insecurity of LGBTQ+ people in the Russian state and accept that this state is dangerous for them.
    2. Migri has to provide safety for all LGBTQ+ asylum seekers from Russia regardless of whether they faced violence in Russia or not before coming to Finland.
    3. The criteria for assessing asylum have to be based on the assessment of the need for safety and not on the evaluation of “deservingness” of asylum in Finland.

    In addition, Borderlines supports the demands made in the petition by Anna Iliukovich-Strakovskaia and Victoria Tsvetkova, with the small correction that in our opinion asylum should be given to any LGBTQ+ individuals from Russia, and not only open LGBTQ people or activists.

    You can help LGBTQ+ asylum seekers from Russia to fight for their humanity

    Alexey:

    “…by spreading information about our problems, supporting LGBTQIA+ organizations, and advocating for the reform of migration laws.”

    Maria:

    “Another way is to raise awareness ….—whether individually or in small groups—by getting media attention on the struggles of LGBTQ asylum seekers from Russia.”

    Author’s addition

    (originally published: April 24, 2025)

    How to cite this article (APA style)

    Borderlines. (2026, May 27). LGBTQ+ asylum seekrs from Russia and Migri: facing a death sentence in disguise. Available at: https://borderlinesfi.blog/en/2026/05/27/lgbtq-asylum-seekers-from-russia-and-migri-facing-a-death-sentence-in-disguise/ (Accessed: your date)

    References
    • Healey, D. (2004). «Russia». An Encyclopedia of Gay, Lesbian, Bisexual, Transgender, and Queer Culture.
    • Kosilkin, S. & Kochekovskiy (2024) The rights of LGBT-people in war-time Russia. (Russian: Косилкин, С., Кочековский, А. (2024). Права ЛГБТ-людей в России военного времени. Берлин. Quarteera e. V. стр. 21)
  • Racism: how can your phone help?

    Migrants are often perceived as outsiders, “them”, who are not “us”. This “they-ness” can pop up in people’s minds when they notice some visible features of people around them, like skin color. Being “them” can also mean being worse than “us” (Taylor & Hassan, 2022). In Finland, the worse treatment of people with relatively darker skin can take many forms and racism has been a hot topic of recent public debates. One debate was about how common racism in Finland is and how many resources should be used for its eradication (YLE, 2023; YLE, 2024; Elinkeinoelämän valtuuskunta, 2024).

    There is a mismatch between what some Finns, and especially PS and Kokoomus supporters, think about how prominent racism is and how many migrants and people of color experience it.

    According to the 2023 report by the European Union Agency for Fundamental Rights, Finland ranks as the 3rd most racist country out of 13 European countries surveyed. Governments, political parties or police, for instance, may hide or ignore unequal treatment of people done both by authorities and ordinary people or even treat people of color worse themselves. Still, governments and political parties can refuse to show others some part of social reality, and so it can become invisible for a large group of people in a society. To resist this, people can start showing what happens in society themselves in order to challenge existing inequalities.

    Digital technology like mobile phones and social media is very important in doing this because it allows people connect and share their ideas much more easily (Taylor, 2023). Mobile phones allow people quickly record whatever they see themselves and instantly share it with others from different areas of the world. This is one of the important reasons why Black Lives Matter movement became so popular. One of the BLM aims was to show some part of social reality that many white people couldn’t see: police brutality towards people of color in the US. Thanks to recording how police officers acted to people of color and sharing it in social media, this issue became a hot topic in American public and made some people go out for a protest against this.

    In Finland, the invisibility of racism can also be challenged by those who record what happens to people of color and share such videos with many others (Oosi & Näveri. 2024). For example, on 12.10.2024 Alaa Altamimi and his friends wanted to go to the Jackie bar where they wanted to listen to their friends’ music band. They and many other people of color couldn’t do this because the bar worker didn’t let them in. Their white friends could pass without problems though. You can read the details about what happened on Alaa’s account. Alaa recorded the incident on his phone camera and sent it to the Non-Discrimination Ombudsman’s office. As a result of this, his video was studied and the head of the unit at their office Robin Harms expressed his concern that the behaviors of both police and the bar worker look problematic and should be studied more thoroughly. Alaa also used his videos to share what happened with YLE journalists, who published ab article about the incident and made it more visible for many people.

    Recording racism

    It’s important to share videos that feature racism respecting others’ rights for privacy and avoiding fines.

    The Finnish Data Protection Act (1050/2018) and the EU’s General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) determine when someone’s personal info cannot be shared on social media.

    Defamation involves spreading false information or insinuations about another person that could cause damage or suffering and is described in Chapter 24, Section 9 of the Criminal Code.

    Even true statements can be considered defamatory if they are presented in a manner intended to harm someone’s reputation.

    How to record videos when you or someone you know faces racism in Finland:

    1. Anonymize Details
    • Omit or alter identifying details to protect individuals’ identities.
    • Blur a person’s face or other specific details that make a person easily recognizable by others, remove an audio track if someone’s voice is distinctive.
    • Do not mention a person’s name or other easily identifiable features even after you have blurred a face or removed an audio.

    2. To avoid defamation claims:

    • Share information that serves as the evidence of what happened.
    • Avoid making evaluating claims about the place wherethe incident has happened. Focus on describing details of what happened and how you felt about it.
    • Racist behaviors are very unpleasant so give yourself some time to cool down to avoid posting something impulsively.

    (originally published: December 19, 2024)

    How to cite this article (APA style):

    Borderlines. (2026, May 26). Recording racism. Available at: https://borderlinesfi.blog/en/2026/05/26/recording-racism/ (Accessed: your date)

    References
    • Taylor, S., and Hassan, I. (2022) ‘Identities’, in Clarke, J., Doyle, Z., Hassan, I., and Woodward, K. (eds) Understanding social lives, part 2. 2nd edn. Milton Keynes: The Open University, pp. 1-44
    • Taylor, D. (2023) “The smartphone as a tool for change’, in P. Redman (ed.) Global challenges: social science in action 1. Milton Keynes: The Open University, pp. 47-73.

  • In society there are many different categories someone can belong to, and sometimes one can belong to more than one. One can be a disabled migrant woman or a gender noncomforming homeless Roma person.

    Intersectionality is the idea that when some people belong to several categories, this creates unique problems, discrimination, and privilege. In social groups and activist movements, such people face unique challenges and may feel excluded (Taylor & Hassan, 2022).

    This is Nikki Obernik’s experience based on his life in Finland. Nikki belongs to several categories: he is a gay, migrant, cosmopolitan, married man who can’t come back to the source country and who has a Russian background.

    “I saw many Russian circles who provide a niche for Russians who feel excluded from Finnish society and yet if you are gay, oppose Putin’s regime and cosmopolite, you’d feel that you can’t share some parts of your own identity or if you do, you’d feel misunderstood or even separated, which can lead to people stop helping you and being nice to you.

    I couldn’t become part of LGBTQ+ circles which are often Finnish. Of course, being a Finnish LGBTQ+ person looks like privilege in comparison with a migrant, who has to deal with their resident permits, salary thresholds, employment, migrant/ethnic/racial discrimination in general, language barriers etc – a whole world that isn’t so much familiar or even interesting for Finnish queer people. What I faced was often the lack of solidarity and indifference when I talked about how temporary residence permit holders can’t get married in Finland or what a horror it is to be constantly worried about your residence when you only have temporary work contracts, feel exhausted, and can’t go back.

    Refugee circles mainly focus on those who have the official status of refugees or asylum seekers, yet again not everyone who flees from the real or potential danger of prosecution applies for asylum. This group excludes other migrants who come on the basis of work or studies and yet feel that they can’t go back. Renewing our residence permits and facing restrictions on where we can work or study feels different from those who get an asylum-based residence permit. In turn, migrant circles don’t pay much attention to those who are afraid of potential deportation due to threats in the source country and whose experience of migration is again different.

    Does it really make sense to make more and more very specific groups for disabled migrant gays from India, cosmopolitan unemployed people with mental issues, or divorced mothers of color? Probably not, because there is indefinite number of combinations of categories you may belong and no group focusing on just one specific issue will ever be enough.”

    (originally published: September 10, 2024)

    How to cite this article (APA style)

    Borderlines. (2026, March 17). Intersectional obstacles. Available at: https://borderlinesfi.blog/en/2026/03/17/326/ (Accessed: your date)

    References
    • Taylor, S., and Hassan, I. (2022) ‘Identities’, in Clarke, J., Doyle, Z., Hassan, I., and Woodward, K. (eds) Understanding social lives, part 2. 2nd edn. Milton Keynes: The Open University, pp. 1-44

  • Exploitation of immigrants means an unjust situation when an employer gets benefits from an immigrant worker’s disadvantages.

    How does exploitation of migrant workers look like in Finland?

    • paying less than required in the work agreement
    • paying less to migrants than to Finns demanding working for long hours so that workers have little or no free time
    • not letting a worker to have other work contracts outside their first work
    • providing workers with bad apartments / living conditions
    • taking a worker’s documents away such as their passport
    • threatening a worker or their family (Ollus, 2016). 

    Exploiting workers, employers may abuse what a worker is vulnerable in:

    – lack of language skills

    – lack of contacts with people and organizations

    – not knowing workers’ rights

    In order to exploit, employers can

    – manipulate with work contracts

    – lie to a worker about working conditions (Ollus, 2016)

    In 2022, Liza Kuznetsova arrived at a berry farm next to the lake in Leppävirta, not far from Kuopio, Finland. Unlike others, she already had a residence permit and decided to come to the farm to explore what work there would look like. Besides her, there were about 15 Russians, one Ukrainian and 3 Congolese. Next is what she writes about her experiences of work on the farm. 

    “The conditions were poor. Rooms for 4-8 people in the barracks. Dirty toilet and shower with water which always ends.”

    Lisa also tells that she noticed that her employer lied to her about how long she had to work:

    “Already on the farm employer notified me that conditions have changed and now workers wake up at 3am to start working at 4am (before it was 6am). We have half an hour break at 8am and then work till 2pm.”

    The work on a berry farm was hard:

    “On the first day my backache appeared 15min after I started collecting berries.”

    “Sometimes before bringing another basket to the weights I stood up and couldn’t move for half a minute because whole body was hurt. Fingers became swallowed, red and itchy because of strawberries’ acid and water from the morning rain. Nettle bites. Mosquitos bite twice. That day I managed to collect 15 baskets without taking any breaks, what is approx 60 kg of strawberries.”

    In addition to the hard work of berry picking, Liza found some other unpleasant things about the work she started to do. The wages weren’t calculated by hours worked but by weight of berries collected, so that the total wages appeared much lower:

    “I calculated my salary on that day and by weight it appeared to be 48€! 9 hours of hardest physical work was worth 48€! I hoped that at least I will get my fair minimum salary (81€ = 9€*9h).”

    In addition, the employer paid weight-based wages illegally because those wages were lower than the minimal wage stated in Liza and others’ work contracts.

    “When signing the contract later that day employer hurried me up so I would not read it carefully saying “don’t worry, everyone has the same”. But I pointed on the line about minimum wage and asked whether I can get this one. He said he pays only by weight, because employees work with different speed and now the market price goes down. When I said that it’s simply a Finnish law he changed in face, took the unsigned contract from my hand and said that he will bring me back to the bus stop in the evening if I do not agree with his condition…”

    Reasons of exploitation

    Why is there exploitation of migrant workers in Finland?

    The main reason why exploitation of migrants exists in Finland is globalization.

    Globalization (Humphreys, 2023) means a process in world society when different societies, people, cultures, and countries are getting more connected with each other. With globalization, powerful individuals and organizations can influence distant people and places across the glove.

    Such powerful organizations could be international companies that supply supermarkets in Finland with berries, fruits, other products. Finnish companies now have to compete not only with each other but also with them. As a Finnish company, you’ll be interested in getting profits, which you get when people buy your products. When other companies arrive, you’ll be interested in that Finnish people would buy your products and not the ones of foreign and other domestic companies.

    Liza’s employer mentioned that “now the market price goes down.”

    “Other employees told me that this year there were not enough workers on the farm and many strawberries were already overripe, so you have to spend much more time in selecting the perfect-looking ones and separating them from leaves (new requirement from the employer).”

    As an average person coming regularly to the store to buy some strawberries or blueberries and, say, cook a pie for an evening tea time, you’d be probably interested in the good ones that cost only €6 instead of the good ones that cost €12.

    For a company, it’s reasonable to decrease the price for a package of such strawberries or blueberries, so that when you come to the store, you’d buy their package instead of a foreign one.

    How can a company decrease a price? A company may decrease the salaries of people who work on berry farms before the packages of berries appear in the supermarket. Additionally, a company may spend less for living conditions where workers live or remove worker benefits, that all will decrease the final price for a package of berries.

    “I calculated my salary on that day and by weight it appeared to be 48€! 9 hours of hardest physical work was worth 48€! I hoped that at least I will get my fair minimum salary (81€ = 9€*gh). Thus, physically you couldn’t make enough baskets so that their weight multiplied by the price by kilo (1,06€/kg) would be equal at least the minimum hourly wage (9€/hour) multiplied by the number of hours you work.”

    When salaries fall down and living conditions get worse and benefits disappear, Finnish people may not really be interested in working for such companies. So a company may look for people who would like to come to Finland from other countries and who would accept such conditions.

    Not any person from a foreign country would work in harsh conditions, but often it’s those people who are in need for various reasons. They may need to get some money to pay debts or to care for their heavily diseased parents, to reach the income threshold to get a residence permit and stay in Finland or to bring their family with them. For these people, working in bad conditions allows them to try to reach their needs.

    “Someone told me that Finns would not work for such a low salary, but I have several Finnish friends who went strawberry picking couple of years ago.” “employer intentionally didn’t hire Finns, because they know their rights and will fight for them, while it’s so easy to abuse people in vulnerable situation (like Russians and Ukrainians nowadays) who are afraid to loose even that little they can get there. <…> My roommate appeared to be another Russian girl my age. When we were in the bed she said she is dreaming of pickled cucumbers and a piece of pork fat (tradition dish in Ukraine and Russia). I realised she was hungry and didn’t have nice food for a while. All her food was eggs, bread, instant noodles and sausages.” “When I suggested to buy groceries the next day she said she doesn’t have money and have to pay her debts so she refused. <…> Someone told me that Finns would not work for such a low salary, but I have several Finnish friends who went strawberry picking couple of years ago.” “employer intentionally didn’t hire Finns, because they know their rights and will fight for them, while it’s so easy to abuse people in vulnerable situation (like Russians and Ukrainians nowadays) who are afraid to loose even that little they can get there. <…> My roommate appeared to be another Russian girl my age. When we were in the bed she said she is dreaming of pickled cucumbers and a piece of pork fat (tradition dish in Ukraine and Russia). I realised she was hungry and didn’t have nice food for a while. All her food was eggs, bread, instant noodles and sausages.” “When I suggested to buy groceries the next day she said she doesn’t have money and have to pay her debts so she refused.

    People who arrived in Finland may not speak the local language well and may not know their worker rights well either. Because of this and because of their needs and restrictions (for example, on where can a migrant work), what is inacceptable for Finns may look like or even be one of few choices for them.

    Even when they reveal being exploited, they may still not want to address the issue to a lawyer out of fear of not being able to stay in Finland, to pay their debts, to bring their family members to Finland or other negative consequences. Their vulnerability pushes them to work in exploitative conditions and to even keep them hidden, which, in turn, is beneficial for employers.

    Because foreign workers’ situation is dependent on their employers, they themselves hide the conditions of exploitation in fear of negative consequences for themselves.

    “I came back to the farm and started talking to others:

    Lera: “I know he tricks us but what can we do?”;

    Iskander: “Oh I didn’t know there was some minimum salary. I do not speak English so I didn’t even understand the contract”;

    Irina: “Yeah, I know he underpays me at least twice, but I am in that situation that I need at least some money”.

    Natalia even tried to justify the employer: “The market price goes down, so that’s why he forces us to collect more and underweights the baskets. He needs to adapt. It’s understandable”

    “She was scared. She asked what will be the consequences for her, what if the employer cancels her visa (?), what if they forbid her to enter Finland again.”

    Some people are concerned about companies exploiting migrants or some other groups of people.

    It’s important to remember that not just companies, but consumers are also involved in driving exploitation, and consumers and workers are linked together (Allen, 2022): consumers push companies to decrease their prices, and in order to do that in search for cheap labor companies start to exploit their workers.

    Consumers’ wish to buy cheap products and services (food, cleaning, personal assistance etc) is satisfied at the expense of migrant workers’ security and decent working conditions. That’s why action among consumers is important.

    What can we do?

    We can boycott the companies that harm their workers, that is, avoid buying their products in the stores and as consumers provide a negative feedback on what they do by decreasing their benefits.

    We can “buycott” the companies that switch to working conditions respecting their workers. This means that as consumers, we can prefer buying their products and by this provide a positive feedback on how they act.

    We can also lobby certain policy makers, write petitions, and start campaigns that help those who disagree with how exploiting companies work, unite and demand changes.

    We can produce some information packages or magazines with the lists of companies that exploit their workers or provide them fair work conditions.

    Because exploitation is driven by increased competition between companies due to new companies appearing in local markets as a result of globalization, we can also ease that competition by deliberately choosing the products of local companies who provide fair work and salaries to their workers.

    (originally published: November 12, 2024)

    How to cite this article (APA style):
    References
    • Andorfer, V. (2015) Ethical Consumers, Editor(s): James D. Wright, International Encyclopedia of the Social & Behavioral Sciences (Second Edition), Elsevier, pp. 25-30
    • Humphreys, D. (2023) ‘Global heating: exploring the relationship between the local and the global’, in P. Redman (ed.) Global challenges: social science in action 1. Milton Keynes: The Open University, pp. 75-105
    • Ollus, N. (2016) From forced flexibility to forced labour: the exploitation of migrant workers in Finland. European Institute for Crime Prevention and Control, affiliated with the United Nations (HEUNI): Grano Oy, Tampere, Finland. European Commission. Migration and Home Affairs.